28 Summers Book Review

Elin Hilderbrand, fondly referred to as the “queen of beach reads”, has carved out a unique niche for herself in contemporary literature.

Over the years, she’s gifted readers with sun-soaked tales emanating from the picturesque shores of Nantucket.

While her books often serve as perfect summer companions, the underlying narratives invariably touch upon deeper themes, making them resonate with readers across diverse backgrounds.

It’s this blending of light-hearted atmospherics with profound emotional journeys that have garnered Hilderbrand a loyal fanbase.

“28 Summers” is no exception in her impressive repertoire.

At first glance, the novel seems like a whirlwind romance set against the breezy backdrop of Nantucket, but as the pages turn, readers realize it’s so much more.

It’s a poignant reflection on how time, while unrelenting in its march, can become a canvas for memories, regrets, dreams, and ever-evolving relationships.

The novel provides a unique perspective on the concept of time-bound love, making one reflect on their own relationships and life choices.

Summary of the Plot (No Major Spoilers)

The narrative revolves around Mallory Blessing and Jake McCloud and their annual Labor Day meetings in Nantucket.

These meetings spread across 28 summers, are the backbone of their relationship and the novel.

Each summer serves as a snapshot, not just of their evolving relationship but also of the changing socio-political landscape of America.

Their relationship, clandestine in nature, unfolds in a secluded beach house, which becomes a silent witness to their joys, sorrows, and the many secrets they share.

Hilderbrand masterfully weaves the narrative structure of “28 Summers” around the play “Same Time, Next Year” by Bernard Slade.

The play’s premise, where two individuals meet annually for a romantic tryst despite their separate lives, echoes in the story of Mallory and Jake.

Yet, Hilderbrand gives it a fresh twist, making readers question conventional notions of love and fidelity.

Just like the characters in the play, Jake and Mallory share a connection that defies societal norms and the confines of traditional relationships.

Major Themes and Symbols

The Passage of Time: At its heart, “28 Summers” is a meditation on the passage of time.

With each summer that Mallory and Jake reunite, Hilderbrand paints a vivid tapestry of their evolving emotions, challenges, and individual growth.

But time, in this narrative, is more than just a backdrop; it’s an ever-present force, sometimes kind, often cruel.

The annual meetings serve as poignant reminders of fleeting moments and the impermanence of life.

From the backdrop of political events to changing fashion trends, we’re reminded of the inexorable march of years and the fleeting nature of human experiences.

Love and Commitment: The relationship between Mallory and Jake is central to the story, and through it, Hilderbrand delves deep into complex themes of love and commitment.

Their bond challenges societal notions of what it means to be truly committed.

Can love that’s bound by time, only flourishing for a few days a year, hold the same depth and intensity as one lived daily?

The story forces readers to reconsider conventions and understand that love’s essence can’t always be captured within societal norms.

Nantucket: Nantucket isn’t just a setting in the story; it’s a symbol.

The island, with its serene beauty and timelessness, mirrors the love between Mallory and Jake.

It becomes a haven where they escape from the world, a place unchanging in its essence even as the years roll by.

Just like their love, Nantucket remains constant amidst the shifting sands of time.

Character Analysis

Mallory Blessing: Mallory is a character of depth and complexity.

Over the 28 summers, we see her evolve from a young woman full of dreams and aspirations to someone who grapples with the weight of choices and their consequences.

Her beach house in Nantucket serves as both her sanctuary and the venue for her most profound life experiences.

While Mallory’s journey is marked by love, it’s also punctuated by personal growth, challenges, and the bittersweetness of life’s ephemerality.

Jake McCloud: Jake’s journey is no less captivating.

When we first meet him, he’s a young man on the cusp of life, filled with ambition and the invincibility of youth.

As the years pass, we witness his transformation into a significant political figure, with the weight of responsibilities and societal expectations bearing down on him.

Yet, amidst the chaos of his external world, his love for Mallory remains his true north.

Their annual meetings become his anchor, a reminder of a simpler time and the purity of their bond.

Secondary Characters: Hilderbrand populates the world of “28 Summers” with a rich tapestry of secondary characters.

Each one, from Mallory’s brother to Jake’s wife, adds depth and dimension to the narrative.

They aren’t mere bystanders; they influence, challenge, and often serve as reflections of the main protagonists’ inner struggles and joys.

Writing Style and Narration

Evocative Prose: Elin Hilderbrand’s writing in “28 Summers” is both poignant and evocative.

She paints a vivid picture of sun-soaked days on Nantucket, capturing the essence of summer in all its glory: the shimmering heat, the scent of saltwater, the lazy afternoons.

Every description, every passage, feels like a sensory experience, transporting readers directly to the heart of the island.

Yet, beyond the scenic beauty, Hilderbrand’s prose shines in its ability to tap into the raw emotions of the characters.

Through simple words, she conveys the depths of love, the anguish of separation, and the complexity of human relationships.

There’s an elegance in her simplicity, allowing readers to connect deeply with the story and its protagonists.

Narrative Structure: “28 Summers” stands out for its unique narrative approach.

By structuring the book around the annual Labor Day meetings, Hilderbrand employs a nonlinear timeline, which could have been risky.

However, she masterfully ensures continuity, connecting each summer to the next with seamless transitions.

This alternating timeline adds depth to the narrative, offering readers snapshots of Mallory and Jake’s lives.

It serves as a window into their world, capturing the changes, both subtle and profound, that mark each year.

The structure creates anticipation and builds intimacy, as readers are privy to the couple’s most cherished secret, their time-bound love.

Personal Reflections and Experiences

Emotional Resonance: Reading “28 Summers” is not just a literary experience; it’s an emotional journey.

As Mallory and Jake navigate the complexities of their relationship, readers are compelled to reflect on their own life choices, relationships, and the concept of time.

There were moments when the narrative evoked feelings of nostalgia, reminiscent of personal summer memories and fleeting romances.

Thought-Provoking Moments: There are certain junctures in the narrative that force introspection.

The story, in many ways, challenges conventional notions of love and fidelity.

It raises questions: Can love be bound by time?

Can it thrive in secrecy and still remain genuine?

What does it truly mean to be committed?

Hilderbrand doesn’t necessarily provide answers but encourages readers to grapple with these dilemmas, making the reading experience deeply personal and contemplative.

Comparisons to Hilderbrand’s Other Works

A Signature Style, Yet Distinct: Elin Hilderbrand has made a name for herself with novels that exude a quintessential summer atmosphere, largely set against the idyllic backdrop of Nantucket.

Fans of her work might recognize familiar elements in “28 Summers”, the picturesque descriptions, the intricate relationships, and the emotional depth.

Yet, this novel stands distinct in its approach to love and time.

Compared to other novels like “The Perfect Couple” or “The Identicals,” “28 Summers” possesses a more restrained narrative, focusing deeply on just two main characters’ evolution.

While her other works often delve into family dynamics or community intricacies, this book narrows down to the private universe of two souls.

Evolution of Hilderbrand’s Themes: Over the years, Hilderbrand’s novels have touched on various themes; love, betrayal, family, secrets, and more.

In “28 Summers,” she pushes her thematic boundaries by delving deeper into the concept of time-bound love.

It feels like a natural progression from her previous works, marrying her established storytelling expertise with fresh, thought-provoking motifs.

Critiques and Areas of Improvement

Pacing Concerns: While the structure of covering 28 summers is novel and intriguing, it can occasionally feel like certain years or events are rushed.

Given the scope of the timeline, some summers naturally receive more attention and detail than others.

For some readers, this might result in a desire for more depth in specific sections or a feeling of abrupt transitions.

Character Choices: While Mallory and Jake’s relationship forms the heart of the narrative, some of their choices might be polarizing for readers.

Certain decisions they make, especially in the context of their annual meetings, might seem perplexing or even frustrating.

However, it’s essential to remember that Hilderbrand paints her characters with shades of grey, making them human, fallible, and hence, relatable.

Secondary Characters’ Utilization: While the book does feature secondary characters that add depth to the story, there are moments when they feel underutilized or overshadowed by the towering presence of Mallory and Jake. Expanding on these characters could have provided varied perspectives and richer layers to the narrative.

Reader Reactions and Reception

A Polarizing Novel: “28 Summers” has garnered varied reactions from its readership.

Many laud it as one of Hilderbrand’s most profound works, praising the intricate portrayal of love outside societal norms and the innovative narrative structure.

They find the emotional depth and the year-by-year progression both refreshing and heartrending, creating a roller-coaster of emotions.

However, some readers have expressed reservations.

Certain aspects of the relationship between Mallory and Jake, especially given its clandestine nature and the choices they make vis-à-vis their other commitments, can be a point of contention.

For some, this has raised ethical dilemmas that occasionally overshadow the novel’s broader themes.

Book Clubs and Discussions: Given its depth and multifaceted narrative, “28 Summers” has become a favorite among book clubs.

It offers a plethora of discussion points, from the nature of love and commitment to the societal events of the past three decades.

The book’s structure also prompts introspection about the passage of time and the moments that define our lives.

Bestseller Lists and Awards: “28 Summers” enjoyed a significant stint on various bestseller lists, further cementing Hilderbrand’s reputation as a leading contemporary author.

While accolades and awards are a testament to a book’s critical acclaim, the lasting impact of “28 Summers” lies in its ability to resonate with readers, prompting them to reflect, discuss, and revisit the story long after turning the last page.

Symbolism in the Narrative

The Shack: Mallory’s Nantucket shack serves as a powerful symbol throughout the narrative.

It’s not just a meeting point for the lovers; it represents a realm outside of time, a sanctuary from the demands and judgments of the outside world.

As the years progress, the shack retains its essence, even as the world around it changes, symbolizing the unchanging core of Mallory and Jake’s relationship amidst the flux of time.

The Annual Labor Day Weekend: Their repeated encounters over the Labor Day weekend are symbolic of cyclical time, a recurring moment of togetherness amidst the sea of separation.

It’s a poignant reminder of their unique bond, a love that’s both constrained by time yet seemingly timeless in its intensity.

The Ocean: Nantucket’s surrounding ocean is a recurring motif.

It reflects the vastness and depth of their feelings, the ebb and flow mirroring their moments of closeness and separation.

The ocean, with its vast horizon, also symbolizes the infinite possibilities and paths their relationship could take, while simultaneously hinting at the unpredictability of life and love.

Closing Thoughts

A Timeless Tale: While “28 Summers” revolves around the concept of time, its core emotions; love, longing, joy, and regret are timeless.

Hilderbrand has managed to create a story that, while deeply rooted in its yearly chapters, possesses a universality that transcends specific eras.

Impact on Hilderbrand’s Portfolio: With “28 Summers,” Hilderbrand solidifies her position as a luminary in contemporary fiction.

The book, with its unique narrative structure and emotional depth, is a standout, even within her already impressive portfolio.

Anticipation for Future Works: Given the brilliance and depth of “28 Summers,” expectations for Hilderbrand’s subsequent works are high.

If this novel is any indication, readers can look forward to more boundary-pushing, thought-provoking narratives that challenge conventions while tugging at the heartstrings.

Our Rating for “28 Summers”

Plot and Pacing: 4.5/5
Hilderbrand has woven a compelling story, intertwining Mallory and Jake’s relationship with the larger socio-political backdrop of America over nearly three decades.

The year-by-year progression offers a fresh take on storytelling.

While the pacing is generally even and engaging, there are moments where the story might feel slightly stretched, hence the deduction of half a point.

Character Development: 5/5
One of the standout elements of “28 Summers” is the depth and evolution of its characters.

Mallory and Jake are fleshed out with incredible detail, allowing readers to empathize, celebrate, and commiserate with them.

The secondary characters also add richness to the narrative, providing varied perspectives and interactions that enhance the central story.

Writing Style: 4.7/5
Hilderbrand’s evocative imagery and prose are commendable, particularly her descriptions of Nantucket. The innovative narrative structure adds a unique flavor to the reading experience.

However, some readers might find certain sections overly descriptive, slightly affecting the flow.

Emotional Resonance: 5/5
“28 Summers” strikes a chord, eliciting a wide range of emotions.

From the joy of young love to the pangs of longing, from nostalgia for bygone days to the bitter-sweetness of memories, the book resonates deeply, leaving a lasting impact.

Relevance and Societal Commentary: 4.8/5
The integration of real-world events and shifts in societal norms adds depth to the story, making it more than just a love narrative.

It becomes a reflection of American society over three decades.

The slight deduction stems from a few instances where the societal commentary might feel a tad forced or tangential.

6. Overall Enjoyment: 4.9/5
On the whole, “28 Summers” offers an immersive and moving reading experience.

It’s a book that many would revisit, savoring the nuances and layers with each read.

The slight point off is simply an acknowledgment that no book is universally adored, and individual preferences might vary.

Final Average Rating: 4.8/5

In summary, “28 Summers” stands as a testament to Hilderbrand’s storytelling prowess.

It’s a beautifully crafted tale that combines love, history, and societal observation, ensuring a memorable journey for its readers.

The high rating solidifies its position as a must-read, especially for those seeking a deep, evocative narrative that resonates long after the final page.


We genuinely hope our comprehensive review has covered everything you were looking for.

You can also read further reviews on Amazon.

Thank you for reading and we hope to see you back here soon!