A Discovery of Witches Book Review
Click Image for Amazon Link

In the realm of historical fantasy fiction, few authors bring the depth of academic knowledge to their craft like Deborah E. Harkness.

A seasoned historian with a flair for storytelling, Harkness took the literary world by storm with her debut novel, “A Discovery of Witches”.

The book, which smoothly blends the realms of history, fantasy, romance, and the supernatural, serves as the captivating introduction to the ‘All Souls Trilogy.

With its nuanced characters and intricately woven narrative, it beckons readers into a world where witches, vampires, and daemons are not merely creatures of lore but complex beings with histories, desires, and conflicts.

Summary of the Plot (No Major Spoilers)

Set against the hallowed halls of Oxford’s Bodleian Library, our protagonist, Diana Bishop, is a historian first and a witch second.

Trying to distance herself from her magical heritage due to a traumatic past, Diana stumbles upon an enigmatic alchemical manuscript called Ashmole 782.

This discovery sets off a chain of events that thrusts her into the tumultuous world of supernatural politics and intrigue.

The manuscript, believed to hold secrets about the origins and powers of magical creatures, attracts the interest of witches, vampires, and daemons alike, all eager to decipher its mysteries.

Among them is the ancient and enigmatic vampire, Matthew Clairmont.

He is not just interested in the manuscript but also seems inexplicably drawn to Diana herself.

As events unfold, Diana and Matthew find themselves navigating a treacherous path of forbidden attraction, age-old rivalries, and the looming threat that the manuscript poses.

Their journey is not just about evading danger.

It becomes a voyage of self-discovery for Diana, as she grapples with her suppressed powers, her lineage, and her evolving feelings for Matthew.

Meanwhile, Matthew battles the shadows of his long and often tumultuous past while trying to protect Diana from the many supernatural forces that seek to control or destroy her.

This tale of forbidden love and hidden power becomes a thrilling ride through history, magic, and the intricate landscapes of the heart, making “A Discovery of Witches” not just a supernatural tale but a deeply human story set against a backdrop of arcane mysteries.

In summarizing the plot, it’s evident that Harkness’s novel offers more than just another supernatural romance.

It becomes a meditation on power, identity, history, and the lengths one would go to for love and knowledge.

The Bodleian Library, with its rich history and vast collection, serves as a fitting locale for a tale that spans centuries and delves deep into the annals of magic and alchemy.

3. Main Characters

Diana Bishop: At the heart of this intricate tale is Diana Bishop, a historian with a bloodline that boasts powerful witches.

Yet, she distances herself from her magical heritage, preferring the predictability of scholarly pursuits over the chaos of the magical world.

Her discovery of Ashmole 782 inadvertently disrupts this self-imposed exile from magic.

Throughout the narrative, readers witness her evolution from a woman keen on suppressing her powers to someone who gradually embraces her true potential.

Her character is painted with hues of strength, vulnerability, intelligence, and relentless curiosity, making her not just a witch, but a relatable human being navigating complex emotions and events.

Matthew Clairmont: The millennia-old vampire Matthew Clairmont is a complex blend of enigma, charm, and darkness. His age bestows upon him wisdom, but also a haunted past fraught with loss and regret.

As a scientist and a creature of the night, he straddles the worlds of logic and myth, often presenting a juxtaposition between his primal instincts and his scholarly inclinations.

Matthew’s attraction to Diana is immediate and palpable, and as the story unfolds, readers get a glimpse into his fierce protectiveness, his vulnerabilities, and the depths of his emotions.

Aside from these two protagonists, the narrative is enriched by a diverse ensemble of characters from various supernatural realms.

Each, whether friend or foe, brings forth unique dynamics, adding layers to the unfolding drama and enriching the story’s tapestry.

Themes and Analysis

Forbidden Love: One of the most compelling threads of “A Discovery of Witches” is the illicit romance between Diana and Matthew.

Their love, deemed forbidden due to age-old prejudices and laws governing inter-species relationships, becomes a central conflict.

It challenges both characters’ beliefs and forces them and by extension the readers, to question societal norms and the true essence of love.

Their relationship stands as a testament to the idea that love transcends boundaries, even those as ancient and rigid as those set by supernatural beings.

Power & Identity: At the story’s outset, Diana’s denial of her witch heritage signifies a broader theme of self-acceptance and the understanding of one’s own power.

As the narrative progresses, her journey of coming to terms with her identity becomes symbolic of the universal quest for self-realization.

This theme is mirrored in other characters as well, as they grapple with their positions and powers within their respective realms.

History & Knowledge: Given Harkness’s background as a historian, it’s no surprise that the novel revels in historical details, intertwining real events with fictional narratives.

The pursuit of knowledge, both academic and arcane, serves as a driving force for many characters.

The blend of history and magic presents readers with an enriching experience, reminding us that sometimes truth can be as enchanting as fiction.

Conflict & Loyalty: Supernatural politics play a significant role in the novel, highlighting the intricacies of inter-species relationships.

Rivalries, treacheries, and alliances form a convoluted web, pushing characters to question their loyalties and confront their deepest fears.

In diving into these characters and themes, “A Discovery of Witches” offers readers a world that, while brimming with the supernatural, reflects many of the trials, tribulations, and joys of the human experience.

Writing Style

Navigating the delicate landscape of “A Discovery of Witches,” readers are immediately struck by Deborah E. Harkness’s luminous prose.

As a historian, Harkness possesses an unparalleled ability to infuse her narrative with vivid details that transport the reader through time and space.

The setting of Oxford’s Bodleian Library, described with a scholar’s precision and a poet’s flair, immediately immerses one in an atmosphere that is both academic and arcane.

Each page resonates with the aroma of old manuscripts, the whisper of ancient secrets, and the palpable tension of forbidden romance.

Yet, Harkness’s writing is not merely descriptive. It’s emotive.

Her characterization, particularly of Diana and Matthew, is layered and intricate.

Through introspection, dialogue, and action, their complexities are revealed.

The pacing of the story is adeptly managed, balancing moments of high tension with intervals of character deep dives and relationship developments.

The dialogues, whether they concern historical intricacies or the nuances of the heart, are engaging and authentic.

They serve to both educate and evoke, providing insights into the world she’s crafted and the souls that inhabit it.

Comparisons to Other Works

When delving into the realm of supernatural romance and historical fiction, it’s impossible not to draw parallels with other prominent works in the genre.

Fans of series like “Twilight” or “Outlander” might find familiar echoes in the themes of forbidden love or the blend of history with the supernatural.

However, “A Discovery of Witches” sets itself apart with its depth and academic richness.

While many novels in this genre utilize the supernatural as a backdrop for romance or drama, Harkness’s work stands unique in its commitment to historical accuracy and its scholarly exploration of alchemy, science, and magic.

This isn’t just a tale of a witch and a vampire falling in love; it’s a narrative steeped in centuries of history, culture, and arcane knowledge.

Furthermore, unlike many of its contemporaries, “A Discovery of Witches” does not simplify its characters to mere archetypes.

They’re multi-dimensional beings, with desires, fears, and histories that span ages.

This results in a story that, while it shares thematic elements with other works, offers a depth and sophistication that is distinctly its own.

In the vast literary landscape of supernatural tales, “A Discovery of Witches” shines as a beacon, blending the allure of the mystical with the rigor of historical research, offering readers an experience that is as intellectually stimulating as it is emotionally resonant.

Personal Reflection

“A Discovery of Witches” is not just a foray into the world of the supernatural but a testament to the intricate dance of history, romance, and self-discovery.

Upon my first reading, I was captivated not just by the allure of the forbidden romance between Diana and Matthew but by the broader world that Harkness crafts with such finesse.

The richness of detail, the depth of character exploration, and the intertwining of historical elements made the experience both familiar and novel.

Diana’s journey of self-acceptance and empowerment resonated deeply.

It’s a poignant reminder of the battles we all face when coming to terms with our identity, our heritage, and our destiny.

Her transformation from a scholar reluctant to embrace her magical lineage to a formidable witch is both inspiring and relatable.

On the other hand, Matthew’s struggles with his past and his fierce protectiveness over Diana bring to light the complexities of love and the shadows of memories that many of us grapple with.

One of the standout moments in the novel for me was the meticulous description of the Bodleian Library.

Being transported to this historic hub of knowledge, I could almost feel the weight of centuries-old manuscripts and the whispers of age-old secrets.

Harkness’s expertise as a historian shines through here, making the experience immersive and enchanting.

However, like any work of art, “A Discovery of Witches” is not without its imperfections.

Some might find the pacing slow at times, and others might yearn for a deeper exploration of the secondary characters.

But these minor reservations pale in comparison to the tapestry of emotion, history, and magic that the novel weaves.


For those who have a penchant for tales that meld history, romance, and the supernatural, “A Discovery of Witches” is a must-read.

It caters to fans of historical fiction, offering them a narrative enriched with accurate details and intriguing insights.

Simultaneously, lovers of supernatural romance will be enamored by the forbidden love story and the intricacies of a world where witches, vampires, and daemons coexist.

However, a word of caution: the novel dives deep into historical and alchemical details, which might not be everyone’s cup of tea.

Some might find these sections dense, but for those willing to immerse themselves, the rewards are manifold.

Additionally, the themes of love, power, and identity might evoke intense emotions, so those sensitive to such explorations should tread with awareness.

In conclusion, “A Discovery of Witches” offers a harmonious blend of academic rigor and literary enchantment.

Whether you’re a historian at heart, a lover of supernatural tales, or someone in search of a profound narrative about self-discovery, this novel promises an adventure that will linger long after the last page is turned.

The Impact of the Novel on Popular Culture

“A Discovery of Witches” has not just found its way into the hearts of its readers but has also left an indelible mark on popular culture.

Since its release, there has been a noticeable reinvigoration in the historical fantasy genre, proving that readers yearn for narratives that combine scholarly depth with supernatural allure.

The novel’s success has paved the way for other authors to merge detailed historical research with elements of fantasy, pushing the boundaries of both genres.

Furthermore, the tale of Diana and Matthew has transcended the confines of literature and ventured into other media forms.

The TV adaptation brought the story to a broader audience, further establishing the novel’s characters and themes within the collective cultural consciousness.

This adaptation has also spurred discussions about casting choices, representation, and how literary stories evolve when brought to the screen.

The book has also inadvertently boosted tourism to locations mentioned within its pages, particularly Oxford’s Bodleian Library, which many fans now associate with the world of Diana Bishop.

Not to mention, the interest in alchemy, early scientific writings, and historical manuscripts saw a noticeable uptick, highlighting the novel’s influence in bridging the gap between fiction and real-world scholarly pursuits.

Closing Thoughts

In the pantheon of supernatural romance and historical fantasy, “A Discovery of Witches” stands as a monumental work that has redefined both genres.

Deborah E. Harkness’s ability to weave a narrative that is at once intellectually challenging and emotionally evocative is a testament to her prowess as a storyteller.

By merging her academic background with her flair for narrative, she has created a novel that challenges, captivates, and educates its readers.

The legacy of “A Discovery of Witches” is manifold.

At its core, it serves as a shining example of how genre fiction can be elevated to literary heights with the right blend of research, character development, and thematic depth.

The novel also underscores the power of storytelling in bridging the divide between the past and the present, the known and the unknown, the mundane and the magical.

Future authors within the genre will undoubtedly look to “A Discovery of Witches” as a gold standard, a work that deftly balances the demands of historical accuracy with the allure of fantasy.

Readers, on the other hand, will continue to return to its pages, finding solace in its familiar corridors, drawing strength from its protagonists, and seeking inspiration from its tales of love, power, and self-discovery.

Our Rating for “A Discovery of Witches”

Narrative Structure (4.5/5): Harkness’s storytelling prowess is evident in how she intricately weaves a plot that’s both expansive in its scope and intimate in its character exploration.

The narrative flows with a rhythm that’s mostly engaging, with moments of tension balanced by intervals of reflection.

While the pacing is commendable for the most part, there are sections where it slightly lags, demanding patience from the reader.

Character Development (5/5): One of the novel’s crowning achievements is its deep and nuanced characterization.

Diana and Matthew emerge not as mere fictional entities but as living, breathing individuals with whom readers can empathize, cheer for, and at times, even weep for.

The secondary characters, while not explored as deeply as the protagonists, still add depth and richness to the narrative.

Historical & Academic Depth (4.7/5): Harkness’s background as a historian shines brilliantly in the novel.

The descriptions of places, times, and events are meticulous and transportive.

The exploration of alchemy and arcane practices adds a layer of intellectual rigor that’s rare in the genre.

However, some readers might find certain historical digressions a tad overwhelming.

Romantic Elements (4.8/5): The forbidden romance between Diana and Matthew is both intense and tender.

Their relationship evolves organically, steering clear of many clichés often found in supernatural romances.

The chemistry is palpable, the conflicts genuine, and the resolutions, while not always perfect, are emotionally satisfying.

World-Building (4.9/5): Harkness crafts a universe that’s familiar yet teeming with mysteries.

The rules governing the supernatural entities, their histories, and their interactions are well-thought-out and consistent.

The magical world feels as tangible and intricate as the real one, making the suspension of disbelief effortless.

Overall Rating (4.7/5): “A Discovery of Witches” is a masterclass in how to seamlessly blend historical detail, romantic allure, and supernatural elements into a cohesive and enthralling narrative.

While no work is without its flaws, the minor reservations one might have with this novel are overshadowed by its numerous strengths.

It’s a book that not only entertains but also educates and evokes, making it a must-read for fans of the genre and casual readers alike.