A Room With A View Book Review

“A Room With A View”, penned by the esteemed E.M. Forster, stands as a testament to the literary richness of the early 20th century in Britain.

Edward Morgan Forster, while perhaps not as widely discussed as some of his contemporaries in popular circles, was undeniably one of the master storytellers of his time.

Born in the late 19th century, Forster’s writings often bridged the gap between the Victorian and the modern, shedding light on the cultural shifts and growing pains of a rapidly changing society.

Published in 1908, “A Room With A View” arrived during a period of immense transition.

This was the Edwardian era, a brief but significant period that often gets overshadowed by the Victorian era that preceded it and the calamitous World Wars that soon followed.

Yet, it was during this time that many societal norms were being subtly challenged, especially in literature. Forster’s novel captures the zeitgeist of this era perfectly.

Before delving into the story, it’s essential to appreciate the intricate tapestry of historical, societal, and cultural threads that Forster weaves into his narrative.

Summary of the Plot

Our story revolves around the young and impressionable Lucy Honeychurch.

As the novel unfolds, readers find Lucy on a journey to the picturesque city of Florence, Italy.

Though she is a product of her Edwardian upbringing with all its attendant restraints and conventions – Florence, with its Renaissance glory and passionate undercurrents, offers Lucy a tantalizing glimpse into a world outside her sheltered existence.

Lucy’s stay at the Pension Bertolini introduces her to a diverse ensemble of fellow travelers.

These characters, from the overtly conventional to the passionately unorthodox, set the stage for Lucy’s coming-of-age journey.

Among them, the unconventional George Emerson leaves the most significant impression.

Their evolving relationship serves as the backbone of the narrative.

From the stirring backdrop of Florence, including the visceral scene at the Piazza della Signoria where a local is murdered, to the serene yet restrictive English countryside, the settings play as much of a role as the characters themselves.

The turn of events in Italy, notably her unexpected encounters with George, jolt Lucy out of her comfortable but limited worldview.

However, upon her return to England, she finds herself caught once again in the intricate web of societal expectations, leading to her engagement with Cecil Vyse.

Cecil is the epitome of Edwardian gentlemanliness, but his very propriety and detachment contrast sharply with the raw, authentic passion Lucy experienced in Italy.

As Lucy grapples with her feelings and societal expectations, readers are taken on a poignant journey of self-realization and the pursuit of authentic love.

Major Themes and Motifs

“A Room With A View” is more than just a narrative, it’s a rich tapestry of ideas, layered with multiple themes and motifs.

This section provides a lens to explore the deeper undertones of Forster’s work.

Society vs. Individuality: One of the novel’s central conflicts is the tension between societal norms and the call of individual passions.

Lucy stands at the crossroads of this conflict, with the lush Italian landscape urging her to break free and her English upbringing demanding restraint.

The difference between societal propriety and personal happiness is an age-old one, but Forster presents it with an Edwardian nuance, showcasing a time when these tensions were particularly palpable.

The Role of Women: Lucy’s struggle is emblematic of the broader struggle of women during the Edwardian period.

Beneath her love story lies a commentary on the constraints women faced.

From choosing suitable matches to having limited agency, Lucy’s journey highlights the societal expectations for women.

Through her, Forster subtly comments on the dawn of a new feminist consciousness.

The Power of Nature: Forster frequently employs natural landscapes to symbolize his characters’ inner emotions.

The passionate Italian countryside stands in stark contrast to the structured beauty of the English estates.

These settings are not mere backdrops but essential actors in the narrative, influencing characters’ decisions and mirroring their inner tumult.

Culture and Art: A significant aspect of Lucy’s journey in Florence is her interaction with art.

However, Forster doesn’t just celebrate art for art’s sake. Instead, he examines the authenticity of our interactions with it.

Do we truly engage with beauty, or are we trapped in a performance, observing societal conventions of appreciation? This question resonates throughout the novel.

Character Analysis

Forster’s characters, while shaped by their Edwardian environment, possess a timelessness.

They could easily belong to any era, a testament to Forster’s deep understanding of human nature.

Lucy Honeychurch: Beginning as a naive young woman with a sheltered perspective, Lucy undergoes a transformative journey.

Her experiences in Italy, particularly with George, compel her to question the life laid out for her.

Throughout the novel, Lucy grapples with her self-awareness and societal expectations, embodying the novel’s central conflicts.

George Emerson: A stark antithesis to the societal norms of the time, George stands as a symbol of authentic emotion.

He challenges Lucy’s established beliefs and becomes the catalyst for her self-discovery.

Far from being just a romantic interest, George’s interactions with Lucy offer readers a deeper insight into Forster’s commentary on society.

Cecil Vyse: If George is the embodiment of raw passion, Cecil represents the confines of Edwardian society.

His character is a complex mixture of propriety and detachment, making him an essential figure in Lucy’s journey.

Cecil’s interactions with Lucy highlight the emotional disconnect that can arise when societal expectations overshadow genuine human connection.

Other Supporting Characters: Characters like Charlotte Bartlett, Lucy’s overbearing cousin, and Mr. Beebe, the affable clergyman, are vital to understanding the Edwardian world Lucy navigates.

They provide both contrasts and reflections of Lucy’s internal struggles, adding richness to the narrative landscape.

Writing Style and Structure

Diving into Forster’s “A Room With A View” is akin to entering a beautifully constructed musical symphony.

His style is distinctive, combining elements of wit, irony, and keen observation, resulting in a harmonious narrative flow.

Use of Wit, Humor, and Irony: Forster doesn’t just tell a story; he converses with the reader.

Throughout the novel, his wit shines through, adding levity to even the most serious situations.

His humor is never forced; instead, it bubbles up naturally, often through character interactions and observations.

And then, there’s the irony, a tool Forster employs with precision.

He critiques society, art, and relationships with a gentle, ironic touch, letting the reader come to their own conclusions.

Narrative Voice: Forster’s narrative voice in “A Room With A View” is somewhat omniscient, allowing readers access to the internal thoughts and feelings of various characters.

However, there’s an intimacy to it.

While the narrative is third-person, Forster often dives deep into Lucy’s psyche, granting readers a front-row seat to her transformation.

The juxtaposition of Scenes: Forster is a master of contrast.

The vivid Italian landscapes versus the more subdued English countryside serve as a constant backdrop to Lucy’s internal journey.

Through this juxtaposition, Forster elevates settings to more than mere locations; they’re instrumental in driving the narrative and its themes.

Historical and Social Context

Understanding the backdrop against which “A Room With A View” was penned offers a deeper appreciation of its content.

The Edwardian era, while short-lived, was a period of considerable change, and Forster’s novel captures its essence beautifully.

Edwardian England: Following the long and strict Victorian era, the Edwardian period felt like a brief breath of fresh air before the upheaval of the World Wars.

There was a certain lightness and optimism in the air, but also an underlying tension as the old world clashed with the new.

Forster’s novel, set against this backdrop, amplifies these tensions, especially as they pertain to love, class, and societal norms.

Social Mores and Class Structure: While the Edwardian era was progressive in many ways, it still held onto many societal conventions from the Victorian age.

Class distinctions were palpable, and there were stringent expectations around behavior, especially for women.

Lucy’s journey, her struggle with societal expectations versus personal desires, mirrors the broader societal tensions of the time.

Early 20th-century Literary Scene: When situating “A Room With A View” in the literary scene of the time, it’s worth noting that this was a period of blossoming modernism.

Writers were experimenting with form and challenging conventional narratives.

In that context, Forster’s novel was both a nod to the traditional and a step toward the contemporary.

Personal Reflection and Critique

To truly delve into the heart of “A Room With A View”, one must go beyond mere academic analysis.

Engaging with the novel on a personal level reveals layers of meaning and emotions that resonate deeply.

Resonance with Modern Readers: Despite its Edwardian setting, the novel speaks to the perennial human condition; our battles with societal expectations, our quests for authentic connections, and our longing for self-discovery.

Lucy’s journey can be seen as a universal coming-of-age tale, reflecting the dilemmas that many face when navigating between convention and individual desires.

As a reader, I found myself rooting for Lucy, her joys becoming my joys, her dilemmas mirroring many I’ve faced in my own life.

Feelings Evoked: Forster’s lyrical prose has a way of immersing readers in the world he paints. The vivid landscapes, the nuanced character dynamics, and the emotional crescendos made me feel a gamut of emotions—from the exhilarating freedom of the Italian vistas to the stifling rigidity of Edwardian England. The novel serves as a poignant reminder of the cost of sacrificing one’s desires for societal acceptance.

Criticisms and Contemporary Lens: While “A Room With A View” is undoubtedly a masterpiece, one must approach it with the understanding that it is a product of its time. Some might argue that certain character portrayals or societal views reflect dated notions. However, even within those constraints, Forster manages to challenge many of the norms of his day, making his work progressive in its essence.

Closing Thoughts

To encapsulate “A Room With A View” is no easy task, it’s a novel of both quiet moments and roaring passions.

The narrative beautifully captures the twilight of an era, representing the transitional phase from the Victorian to the modern.

Lucy Honeychurch’s journey from naivety to self-awareness is both a product of the Edwardian zeitgeist and a timeless exploration of self-discovery.

Its enduring appeal lies in the delicate balance it strikes between societal critique and personal narrative.

The intricate dance of characters, themes, and settings crafts a story that’s as compelling as it is insightful.

For those seeking both a romantic narrative and a profound exploration of societal norms, “A Room With A View” is a delightful and enriching experience.

It’s not just a book; it’s a journey, a sentiment, a view into a world where personal desires and societal expectations collide.

Our Rating for “A Room With A View”

Rating a literary work is never a straightforward task; it involves weighing multiple aspects of the book, both tangible and intangible.

As we consider “A Room With A View,” it’s crucial to approach the rating not just from an academic perspective but also in terms of its emotional impact and contemporary relevance.

Narrative and Plot: 9/10

The narrative arc of “A Room With A View” is undoubtedly one of its strengths.

Forster masterfully intertwines the personal journey of Lucy Honeychurch with broader societal commentaries.

While the plot takes readers on a geographical journey from Florence to England, it simultaneously embarks on a more profound introspective journey.

One point is deducted because some readers might find certain sections a tad slow-paced.

Character Development: 10/10

Forster’s characters are his pièce de résistance.

Lucy’s evolution from a sheltered girl to a self-aware woman is both delicate and profound.

Supporting characters, from the passionate George Emerson to the restrained Cecil Vyse, add depth and color to the narrative.

Each character, irrespective of their screen time, leaves an indelible mark on the reader.

Writing Style: 9.5/10

Forster’s prose is evocative, flowing effortlessly from the serene English countryside to the pulsating heart of Florence.

His use of wit, irony, and vivid descriptions make the reading experience immersive.

The 0.5 deduction is because, for some contemporary readers, certain passages might feel a tad verbose.

Themes and Social Commentary: 10/10

The themes explored in “A Room With A View” are its backbone.

From societal conventions, and the role of women, to the age-old conflict between individual desires and societal norms, Forster delves deep without ever becoming preachy.

His nuanced portrayal of Edwardian England offers readers both a history lesson and a mirror to modern times.

Emotional Resonance: 9/10

For many readers, Lucy’s journey will strike a chord.

The emotions the book evokes, from the thrill of first love to the stifling weight of societal expectations, are universal. The novel manages to capture the essence of human emotion beautifully.

The one-point deduction comes from the understanding that certain readers might not fully connect with the Edwardian setting and its intricacies.

Contemporary Relevance: 8.5/10

While set in Edwardian times, many of the novel’s core conflicts remain relevant.

The societal pressures, the quest for authenticity, and the struggle for self-identity are timeless themes.

However, a 1.5-point deduction is given as some of the novel’s specific societal nuances might feel distant to the contemporary reader.

Overall Rating: 9.3/10

“A Room With A View” stands as a testament to Forster’s storytelling prowess.

While firmly rooted in its time, the novel transcends its era, speaking to readers across generations.

Its blend of romance, societal critique, and deep introspection makes it a must-read for anyone seeking both entertainment and depth in literature.

This rating is a reflection of the novel’s strengths and its few minor shortcomings when viewed through a modern lens.

However, its overall impact is undeniable, making it a timeless classic in every sense.


We genuinely hope our comprehensive review has covered everything you were looking for.

You can also read further reviews on Amazon.

Thank you for reading and we hope to see you back here soon!