Fix Her Up Book Review
Click Image for Amazon Link

“Fix Her Up” by Tessa Bailey landed in my hands after countless recommendations from fellow contemporary romance enthusiasts.

Tessa Bailey, known for her distinctive voice in romance literature, takes on a playful yet emotionally charged journey in this narrative.

In the world of modern love stories, “Fix Her Up” teases readers with a blend of romance infused with humor and raw sentiments.

I picked up this book on a quiet Saturday evening, looking for an escape, and the world of Georgette Castle and Travis Ford certainly provided one.

Summary (Avoid Spoilers)

The story is set in a quintessential small town where everybody knows everybody, and reputations are hard to shake off.

Our heroine, Georgette Castle (fondly known as Georgie), is the town’s youngest resident and is somewhat of an anomaly.

Professionally, she’s a clown, a job that doesn’t do her any favors in being taken seriously as an adult, especially by those who’ve seen her grow up.

Enter Travis Ford; a former baseball professional, who returns to his hometown after an injury cuts his career short.

Deemed the town’s golden boy, his fall from grace is both a town spectacle and a personal crisis.

As he grapples with feelings of inadequacy and an uncertain future, his path crosses with Georgie’s in the most unexpected of ways.

Georgie, fed up with being treated as the perpetual kid sister by her community and, most painfully, by her crush Travis, decides it’s time for a change.

She’s ready to be seen, to be respected, and to break free from the molds that have been set for her.

Travis, on the other hand, needs to shake off his “bad boy” image if he’s to embark on a new career off the field.

In a twist of events, they find themselves entering a “fake relationship,” setting in motion a series of events that neither anticipated.

While the relationship starts as a mere façade, it becomes a catalyst for personal growth, self-discovery, and, of course, undeniable romantic tension.

Character Analysis

Starting with our effervescent heroine, Georgette “Georgie” Castle is a breath of fresh air.

In a genre filled with often predictable leads, Georgie stands out with her unique profession and her undying spirit.

As the youngest in her family, she’s perpetually swathed in their overprotective nature, and the townsfolk never let her forget her place as the bubbly little Castle girl.

Yet, beneath her cheerful facade, there’s a yearning.

A yearning to be acknowledged for more than just her childhood antics or her clown gigs.

Bailey paints a picture of a young woman coming into her own, setting boundaries, and most importantly, learning to voice her desires.

Then there’s Travis Ford; returning to his hometown wasn’t on his agenda, especially not under the cloud of a prematurely ended baseball career.

Once celebrated for his athletic prowess, he’s now battling his own internal demons.

The feeling of inadequacy, the looming uncertainty of his future, and the weight of the town’s collective pity plague him.

But, beneath his rough exterior and “bad boy” reputation, lies a vulnerability that’s poignant and heartrending.

Bailey expertly delves into the psyche of a man redefining his self-worth and identity.

Supporting characters, such as Georgie’s siblings and Travis’s former teammates, provide depth to the narrative.

Their interactions, opinions, and subplots contribute to the fabric of the tale, ensuring that the story isn’t just about our main duo but about a community in flux.

Writing Style

Tessa Bailey’s penmanship in “Fix Her Up” is nothing short of exquisite. Her narrative voice is a delightful mix of sassy, sweet, and soulful.

Scenes transition smoothly, keeping readers entrenched in the unfolding drama.

One of Bailey’s strengths lies in her dialogues.

They are witty, sharp, and often laden with subtext. It’s through these dialogues that we witness the spark between Georgie and Travis, feeling their push-pull dynamic in every exchanged word.

Equally commendable is Bailey’s ability to balance the lighter moments with deep emotional introspection.

Just when you find yourself chuckling at a humorous quip, she effortlessly pulls at your heartstrings with a raw, emotional revelation.

Certain scenes, especially those involving intimate conversations between Georgie and Travis, showcase Bailey’s skill in weaving vulnerability with romance.

Furthermore, the settings and atmosphere she creates are palpable.

The small-town vibe, with its shared histories, interconnected lives, and unavoidable gossip, is depicted in a manner that’s both nostalgic and realistic.

You can almost hear the distant chatter of townsfolk and feel the warmth of the close-knit community.


“Fix Her Up” isn’t just a romance; it’s a commentary on the ways society often boxes us into roles based on past actions, familial ties, or even professions.

At the heart of this novel are two souls struggling to redefine themselves, trying to break free from societal constraints.

Georgette Castle’s battle against the town’s perceptions is a nod to every individual who’s felt limited by external expectations.

Her journey from the ‘town’s little sister’ to a self-assured woman is emblematic of the struggle many face in breaking free from childhood labels.

It’s a resonant theme, reminding readers of the importance of self-belief and perseverance.

For Travis, the theme of rediscovery takes center stage.

How does one redefine oneself after the loss of a career that was so integral to one’s identity?

Bailey beautifully explores the fear, self-doubt, and ultimately the redemption that comes with self-reinvention.

Furthermore, the novel touches on the significance of vulnerability in relationships.

The “fake relationship” trope, while providing comedic moments, also serves as a lens through which Bailey examines the facades people wear and the authenticity that love demands.

Strengths and Weaknesses

Among the strengths of “Fix Her Up” is Bailey’s knack for crafting authentic characters.

Georgie and Travis are not just figments of romance fiction; they’re breathing, flawed, hopeful individuals whose readers can see parts of themselves.

The chemistry between them is palpable, not just in passionate moments but in the quiet, introspective ones too.

Their growth arcs, both individually and together, are expertly woven, making their eventual union all the more satisfying.

Additionally, the balance between humor and deep emotional moments ensures that the narrative doesn’t get too heavy, making it a delightful read from start to finish.

However, no book is without its critiques.

Some readers might find certain tropes used in the story to be cliché or predictable.

The “fake relationship” premise, while engaging, is not a new concept in romance literature.

Additionally, while Bailey does a fantastic job with our lead characters, some secondary characters might come across as underdeveloped or one-dimensional to certain readers.

Lastly, for those seeking a purely realistic take on romance, some scenarios in the book might seem a tad too fantastical or convenient.

But then, that’s the charm of romance novels; they provide an escape; and “Fix Her Up” does that splendidly.

Personal Reflection

From a personal standpoint, “Fix Her Up” struck a chord in a rather unexpected way.

Georgie’s journey, her battle against the long-established labels and perceptions, was something I could deeply relate to.

Haven’t we all, at some point in our lives, felt pigeonholed by perceptions, whether by family, peers, or society?

Her desire to step out of the shadow of the ‘little sister’ tag and be recognized for her individuality resonated profoundly with me.

I recall moments in my own life when I was desperate to shake off labels and prove my worth, to be seen beyond the confines of others’ expectations.

This story serves as a reminder that it’s never too late to redefine oneself, chase dreams, and most importantly, seek love and acceptance, both from others and from oneself.

Travis’s storyline, too, was a touching narrative of grappling with unexpected life changes.

His struggle with identity post his baseball career was an intimate exploration of how we often tether our worth to our professions, achievements, or societal accolades.

Watching him rediscover himself, understand his worth beyond his career, and accept love was both touching and enlightening.

Closing Thoughts

In the vast realm of contemporary romance, Tessa Bailey’s “Fix Her Up” stands out not merely as a love story but as an exploration of identity, growth, and self-acceptance.

While it possesses all the hallmarks of a quintessential romance novel; passion, chemistry, and dramatic tension; it goes beyond the superficial to delve deep into the human psyche.

Georgie and Travis, with all their complexities, become the vessels through which Bailey examines the often turbulent journey of self-discovery.

Their growth, both individually and as a pair, is a testament to the transformative power of love and self-belief.

Would I recommend “Fix Her Up”?


Whether you’re a seasoned romance reader or a newbie to the genre, there’s something in this book for everyone.

It’s a tale of love, yes, but also a poignant reminder of the importance of breaking free, of setting one’s own path, and of the beauty that unfolds when two lost souls find solace in one another.

Our Rating for “Fix Her Up”

For a comprehensive assessment of “Fix Her Up”, I’ve broken down the rating into several key components that I consider essential for any remarkable contemporary romance novel.

Plot Development: 4.5/5
“Fix Her Up” offers a delightful blend of the classic romance tropes we love with a unique twist that keeps readers engaged.

While the ‘fake relationship’ trope is familiar territory, Bailey’s fresh take and the personal growth journeys of the protagonists elevate the plot.

Half a point is deducted for the predictability in certain arcs, but overall, it’s a compelling narrative.

Character Depth: 4.7/5
Georgie and Travis are wonderfully fleshed-out characters.

Their backstories, motivations, vulnerabilities, and desires are clear, making readers invest emotionally in their journeys.

The supporting characters, although not as deeply explored, provide a rich tapestry that enhances the main storyline.

Writing Style: 4.8/5
Tessa Bailey’s writing is vibrant and evocative.

She masterfully juggles humor, passion, and depth, ensuring readers experience a gamut of emotions.

Her dialogues are sharp, and her descriptive prose paints vivid images.

A minor drawback might be the pacing in certain sections, but overall, her writing is top-notch.

Themes & Message: 4.6/5
The themes of self-discovery, breaking societal molds, and the transformative power of love are potent throughout the book.

Bailey doesn’t just skim the surface but dives deep, making readers reflect on their own lives.

While the themes are powerfully presented, a slight repetitiveness in some sections led to a small deduction.

Emotional Engagement: 4.9/5
From chuckles to teary moments, “Fix Her Up” is a roller-coaster of emotions.

As a reader, you find yourself rooting for the characters, sharing their highs and lows.

The chemistry between the leads, both emotional and physical, is palpable, ensuring readers remain engaged from start to finish.

Overall Rating: 4.7/5
Combining all aspects, “Fix Her Up” scores an impressive 4.7 out of 5.

It’s a testament to Tessa Bailey’s prowess as a writer and her ability to craft a story that resonates deeply with readers.

While there are minor areas of improvement, the book stands out as a must-read in contemporary romance.