Set amidst the stark contrast of post-war Brighton, “My Policeman” unfurls a poignant narrative penned by Bethan Roberts.

At its heart, it is a story of love, secrecy, and the societal chains that bind individuals to an existence that is far from their true selves.

Through Roberts’ eyes, readers are offered a window into an era where societal views on homosexuality were not only deeply entrenched but also dictated the course of many lives.

In this intimate portrayal, Roberts beautifully navigates the intricacies of love that dared not speak its name, illuminating the shadows of history that many would prefer to forget.

Plot Summary

The story oscillates between two timelines, providing readers with a dual perspective that feels both immediate and reflective.

In the 1950s, we follow the life of Patrick, a diligent policeman, emblematic of law and order, yet leading a life shrouded in secrecy.

While he appears to lead a conventional life with his wife, Marion, in truth, he is deeply in love with Tom, an antiquarian, whose very essence epitomizes the bohemian freedom of the time.

Marion, a schoolteacher, nurtures a profound love for Patrick.

With every page, her longing becomes palpable as she strives to fit into the role of the devoted wife, unaware of her husband’s secret.

Her perspective offers a profound insight into the mindset of those who were inadvertently caught in the crossfire of societal expectations.

As the narrative shifts to the 2000s, the characters are forced to confront the decisions of their past, revealing a profound commentary on how times have changed, yet emotions remain timeless.

In this era, the story is reignited when an elderly Marion and Patrick provide shelter to an ailing Tom, paving the way for secrets to resurface and past wounds to be reopened.

Through Roberts’ narrative, we traverse the quiet streets of Brighton, feel the weight of societal scrutiny, and experience the bittersweet taste of forbidden love.

It’s a story that not only unveils the struggles of the LGBTQ+ community in the mid-20th century but also delves deep into the human heart’s capacity for love, sacrifice, and resilience.

Character Analysis

Patrick: Patrick, the titular ‘policeman,’ is a study in contradictions.

On the one hand, he’s the embodiment of authority and societal norms, a steadfast protector of the law.

But beneath this veneer lies a man torn apart by his own desires, trapped between the love he feels and the expectations he’s bound to uphold.

Roberts paints a deeply sympathetic portrait of Patrick, highlighting the sheer agony of leading a double life in an era that condemned his true self.

His very profession, which demands the upholding of the laws, becomes ironically juxtaposed against his clandestine love affair with Tom.

This inner turmoil and conflict drive the narrative, making Patrick’s journey one of heartbreak and longing.

Marion: Marion, as depicted by Roberts, is the embodiment of the women of her time; loving, nurturing, and hopeful of a simple life filled with love and companionship.

Her unwavering love for Patrick becomes her blessing and her curse.

Throughout the story, her evolution is palpable.

From the naive girl who dreams of marital bliss to the woman who grapples with the realization of her husband’s secret, Marion’s journey is one of pain, understanding, and eventual acceptance.

Her perspective is crucial as it sheds light on the silent sufferers; those who, in trying to fit the mold society carved for them, ended up losing a piece of themselves.

Themes and Symbols

The Secret Life: One of the most potent themes in “My Policeman” is the duality of existence, the life lived in the open versus the one hidden in the shadows.

Patrick’s life epitomizes this duality, where every public action is a mask for a private truth.

Roberts brilliantly uses this theme to explore the struggles and sacrifices of the LGBTQ+ community in a time when their love was deemed illicit.

It’s a reminder of the countless stories that history never recorded, of loves that remained unnamed and unspoken.

Societal Expectations: The weight of societal expectations looms large over the characters in “My Policeman.”

Whether it’s Patrick’s struggle to reconcile his duty with his desire or Marion’s desperate need to be the ideal wife, the story underscores the tragic consequences of living a life molded by others’ expectations.

Roberts uses this theme to critique a society that prized conformity over authenticity, shedding light on the emotional and psychological toll it exacted on individuals.

Love and Sacrifice: At its core, “My Policeman” is a love story or more accurately, stories of love.

Roberts delves deep into the multifaceted nature of love, be it passionate, unrequited, or dutiful.

The novel illuminates how, in the face of adversity, love can both be a source of strength and a reason for sacrifice.

Whether it’s Patrick’s sacrifice of true happiness for societal acceptance or Marion’s sacrifice of her dreams for the sake of her love, the story underscores the lengths to which individuals go, driven by the power of love.

Literary Style and Structure

Bethan Roberts’ “My Policeman” is distinguished not just by its heart-rending content but also by its literary craftsmanship.

Roberts’ prose is a dance of words, evoking deep emotions and creating vivid imagery in the minds of her readers.

Each sentence, layered with subtle nuances, weaves an intricate tapestry that tells a story beyond just the plot.

The choice of using dual timelines in the narrative is nothing short of brilliant.

By juxtaposing the past and the present, Roberts offers a holistic perspective on the lives of her characters.

This structure doesn’t merely serve as a tool for storytelling; it becomes a reflection on memory, change, and the inexorable passage of time.

It creates a seamless blend of nostalgia and confrontation, allowing readers to journey through the joys, sorrows, and revelations of the characters in both timelines.

Moreover, Roberts’ balance between showing and telling is masterfully executed.

She doesn’t indulge in overt exposition; instead, she trusts her readers to piece together the intricate puzzle of emotions, societal pressures, and personal dilemmas.

The dialogues are natural, the descriptions evocative, and the internal monologues deeply introspective.

This delicate balance ensures that the reader is not just an observer but an active participant in the unfolding drama.

Personal Impressions and Reflections

“My Policeman” resonated with me on multiple levels.

While the narrative is set in a time and place far removed from my own experiences, the raw human emotions it portrays are universal.

It reminded me of the countless unsung stories of love and sacrifice that have been overshadowed by societal norms and expectations.

Patrick’s inner conflict and Marion’s unvoiced pain became reflections of the myriad ways in which we all, at some point or another, grapple with our authentic selves in the face of external pressures.

Reading this book was akin to taking a journey through the annals of time, bearing witness to an era where love was both a revolutionary act and a silent rebellion.

It evoked a plethora of emotions, from anger at a society that forced individuals to lead double lives, to sympathy for those caught in its unforgiving grasp, and admiration for their resilience and courage.

In essence, “My Policeman” isn’t just a novel; it’s an experience.

An experience that lingers, prompting introspection, evoking empathy, and serving as a poignant reminder of the sacrifices made by many in the name of love and acceptance.


While “My Policeman” is undoubtedly a unique literary gem, it brings to mind other poignant works that delve into the intricacies of love, societal expectations, and the struggles of the LGBTQ+ community during eras less accepting than our own.

E.M. Forster’s “Maurice” immediately springs to mind. Written in the early 20th century, yet only published posthumously due to its sensitive content, “Maurice” traces the journey of a man coming to terms with his sexuality in an era that wholly rejected it.

Both novels touch on the quiet desperation of living a lie, the agonizing sacrifices made in the name of societal conformity, and the fleeting moments of genuine connection and understanding.

However, where “Maurice” provides a glimmer of hope and a somewhat idealistic ending given the constraints of its time, “My Policeman” leans into the painful reality of its characters’ lives, offering no easy resolutions but instead a complex tapestry of love, loss, acceptance, and regret.

Another comparative work would be Sarah Waters’ “The Night Watch.”

While Waters’ novel revolves around the intricacies of various relationships set against the backdrop of World War II, it too delves deep into the secrets people keep, the masks they wear, and the lengths they go to protect their true selves.

What makes “My Policeman” stand out, however, is its meticulous exploration of the emotional labyrinth that its characters navigate; the depths of their desires, the weight of their sacrifices, and the scars of their choices.

Closing Thoughts

Bethan Roberts’ “My Policeman” is more than just a novel.

It’s a poignant exploration of love in all its multifaceted glory and pain.

Through the dual timelines, Roberts offers not just a story, but a reflection on societal change and personal evolution.

The novel is a mirror, reflecting the trials and tribulations of those who dared to love differently in a world that wasn’t ready to accept them.

While comparisons can be made to other literary works, “My Policeman” carves out its niche through its unflinching portrayal of its characters’ emotional landscapes.

The heartaches, the fleeting joys, the quiet moments of introspection; all are rendered with a sensitivity that touches the soul.

In wrapping up this review, one cannot help but recommend “My Policeman” not just as a piece of historical fiction but as a timeless tale that resonates deeply with anyone who has ever grappled with societal expectations or the complexities of the human heart.

It’s a testament to love’s enduring spirit and the sacrifices we make in its name.

Our Rating for “My Policeman”

Narrative Depth: 5/5

Bethan Roberts crafts a narrative so deep and absorbing that readers will find themselves fully immersed in the world of “My Policeman.”

The story, with its dual timelines, is intricately woven with the complexities of love, sacrifice, and societal expectations.

Roberts doesn’t shy away from diving deep into the emotional psyche of her characters, making the narrative both heart-wrenching and incredibly relatable.

Character Development: 4.5/5

The characters in “My Policeman” are remarkably fleshed out, evolving seamlessly throughout the story.

Patrick’s internal conflict, Marion’s unwavering love and subsequent heartbreak, and Tom’s representation of unbridled passion and freedom; all are portrayed with a realism that breathes life into the pages.

This a minor deduction only because, at times, secondary characters could have been given a touch more depth to further enrich the narrative landscape.

Writing Style: 4.8/5

Roberts’ prose is nothing short of poetic.

Each sentence is meticulously crafted, the dialogues feel genuine, and the descriptions are vividly evocative.

She manages to strike the perfect balance between showing and telling, letting the story unfold naturally while ensuring the readers remain thoroughly engaged.

The slight deduction stems from moments where the pacing felt a tad uneven, particularly in the transitions between the two timelines.

Themes and Symbolism: 5/5

The thematic elements in “My Policeman” are both profound and timely.

Roberts addresses societal taboos, the struggles of the LGBTQ+ community, and the universal human need for love and acceptance with grace and sensitivity.

The novel’s symbolic elements from the stark contrasts of Brighton’s quiet streets to the very profession Patrick embodies serve as poignant reminders of the story’s central themes.

Overall Enjoyment: 4.9/5

From the first page to the last, “My Policeman” is a captivating read.

It tugs at the heartstrings, provokes introspection, and offers a glimpse into a time that, while distant, resonates deeply with contemporary struggles for acceptance and love.

The slight deduction is a personal one, there were moments so raw and poignant that they left a lingering heaviness long after the book was put down.

For readers who appreciate intricate character studies, historical context, and a deep exploration of societal norms and expectations, “My Policeman” is a must-read.

It’s more than just a love story; it’s a reflection on the complexities of the human heart and the timeless struggle for acceptance.

Whether you’re familiar with the struggles of the LGBTQ+ community or simply a lover of beautifully crafted narratives, Bethan Roberts’ masterpiece is bound to leave a lasting impression.