November 9 Book Review

Colleen Hoover, renowned in the world of contemporary romance fiction, brings another heartfelt story to her readers with “November 9”.

Known for her ability to delve into the complexities of human emotions and relationships, Hoover has established a loyal fanbase who adore her unique storytelling methods and her knack for creating endearing characters.

“November 9” is a poignant story of love, loss, and everything in between, with a unique twist of its own; the story is set to take place on the same date, November 9, over several years.

This unique time structure piques interest and sets the stage for a tale that is as unconventional as it is captivating.

The novel falls into the category of contemporary romance but distinguishes itself through its inventive narrative structure.

Plot Summary

The story begins with the two main characters, Fallon, an ex-soap opera star disfigured from a fire, and Ben, an aspiring novelist, meeting coincidentally in a Los Angeles restaurant on November 9.

Despite their differences, a connection sparks between them.

On a whim, they decide to transform this chance encounter into a recurring annual event. They agree to meet each other on the same date, November 9, every year but will lead their separate lives for the rest of the year, with no contact in between these meetings.

This arrangement forms the backbone of the plot, and we watch their relationship grow, shift, and evolve over several years.

The story follows these annual rendezvous, capturing the pair’s deepening feelings, the secrets they keep, the truths they uncover, and the hardships they endure.

Each meeting represents a snapshot of their lives at that point, enabling readers to map out their emotional journey over the years.

As the narrative unfolds, the anticipation of a plot twist looms.

There’s a significant revelation that drastically changes the dynamics between the two characters.

The climax of the story is riveting and impactful, though to avoid spoilers, the specifics of this twist won’t be detailed here.

The story concludes with a resolution that ties the loose ends, providing readers with a satisfying ending that complements the intense emotional journey Fallon and Ben have undergone.

The ultimate fate of their relationship is something readers will have to discover by diving into this poignant tale.

Character Analysis

Fallon, the female protagonist of the novel, is an ex-soap opera star who has had to endure the physical and emotional pain from a fire that has left her scarred.

Despite these external scars, Fallon is portrayed as a strong, compassionate, and resilient character who yearns for love and acceptance.

Her journey of self-discovery and healing is a central aspect of the novel.

Over the course of their November 9th meetings, readers witness Fallon’s emotional growth as she grapples with her insecurities, learns to accept herself, and finds strength in vulnerability.

Ben, the male protagonist, is an aspiring novelist who struggles with his own set of challenges. As the story progresses, Ben’s character evolves in parallel with Fallon’s.

His journey is marked by his struggle with guilt, the exploration of his creative passion, and his longing for a love that seems just out of reach.

Despite his cheerful exterior, he carries a weighty secret, and his character’s development revolves around the inevitable revelation of this secret and its consequences.

Relationship Dynamics

The relationship between Fallon and Ben forms the core of the novel.

Their dynamic is complex, underscored by an immediate connection, shared empathy, and mutual growth.

However, their agreement to meet only once a year also introduces an element of tension and longing.

Their relationship evolves with every November 9th meeting, intensifying in depth and complexity as they share their successes, failures, hopes, and fears.

Writing Style and Narrative Structure

Colleen Hoover has a unique writing style that often combines emotional depth, compelling dialogues, and intricate character development.

In “November 9,” she continues to showcase these traits. Her writing is emotionally charged, making the characters’ joy, pain, struggles, and love tangible for the readers.

An aspect that particularly stands out in “November 9” is the narrative structure.

The plot unfolds on the same date, November 9, over several years.

This inventive approach provides an interesting take on the passage of time, adding a layer of anticipation and suspense to the story.

It creates a sense of emotional urgency while simultaneously painting a comprehensive picture of the characters’ growth over the years.

The story is told from the dual perspectives of Fallon and Ben.

This first-person dual perspective allows readers to understand the thoughts, motivations, and emotional states of both characters.

It adds depth to the characters and the narrative, offering an immersive reading experience.

Critical Analysis

“November 9” has several strengths that make it a standout novel.

One of the most significant is the compelling characters.

Fallon and Ben are not just well-developed, but their emotional journey and growth over the years feel real and relatable.

The emotional depth of the book is another strong point.

The story packs a powerful emotional punch that stays with the reader long after they’ve finished the book.

The unique narrative structure also works in the book’s favor, adding an intriguing dimension to the story.

On the flip side, some readers might find the plot somewhat predictable or might critique the narrative for relying on a significant plot twist.

Some elements of the story might also be viewed as controversial, causing a divide in reader opinions.

The effectiveness of the plot twist is subjective.

For some, it adds an element of surprise and enhances the story’s impact, while for others, it may feel contrived.

The story’s resolution, though satisfying for many, might seem overly convenient or unrealistic to others.

Despite potential criticisms, “November 9” is a moving narrative that explores complex themes and characters, making it a memorable addition to contemporary romance literature.

It holds a mirror to human vulnerability and the power of love, which resonates deeply with readers.


The novel “November 9” touches upon several themes, central to which are:

Love: The story is a powerful exploration of love in its many forms—first love, unrequited love, and enduring love.

Through Fallon and Ben’s relationship, Hoover examines the transformative power of love and its ability to heal, inspire, and change one’s life.

Self-Discovery: Both main characters embark on personal journeys of self-discovery.

Fallon learns to find beauty beyond physical appearance and to redefine her self-worth, while Ben navigates through his guilt and the quest to fulfill his aspirations as a writer.

Personal Growth: The narrative underlines the theme of personal growth.

The story, told over several years, showcases how Fallon and Ben mature and evolve, influenced by their experiences, personal struggles, and each other.

Passage of Time: With its unique narrative structure of unfolding over several years but only on the specific date of November 9, the novel emphasizes the significance of time in shaping people’s lives, decisions, and relationships.

Closing Thoughts

“November 9” is a captivating journey of love, self-discovery, and emotional growth, painted against the backdrop of a unique narrative structure.

Its appeal lies in its exploration of complex human emotions, character growth, and the profound connection between two individuals.

The story will especially resonate with fans of contemporary romance and character-driven narratives, but its exploration of personal growth, self-acceptance, and the passage of time give it a broader appeal.

Colleen Hoover’s strength lies in her ability to create complex characters, and in “November 9,” both Fallon and Ben are a testament to that.

Their vulnerabilities, strengths, dreams, and fears are explored in depth, making them relatable and real to the readers.

The book also delivers a powerful message about self-love, acceptance, and the transformative power of love, making it more than just a love story.

Despite some potential criticisms, “November 9” stands as a testament to Hoover’s ability to write emotionally resonant stories that leave a lasting impact.

The emotional journey it takes readers on is compelling, and the novel is a highly recommended read for anyone looking for a book that explores love and life in a profound way.

Our Rating

Assigning a final rating to “November 9” can be subjective as it often depends on individual reader preferences.

However, considering the compelling characters, engaging plot, emotional depth, and unique narrative structure, the book holds significant merit.

On a scale of 1-5, “November 9” might be rated around 4.2.

The nuanced character development and emotionally charged narrative are definite strengths, contributing to this rating.

The innovative narrative structure, unfolding over the same date over several years, adds intrigue and anticipation, further enhancing the book’s score.

The minor points of criticism such as potential predictability and the controversy around certain plot elements might slightly affect the rating for some readers.

But overall, the novel’s strengths overshadow its weaknesses, making it a highly enjoyable read in the contemporary romance genre.

As with all ratings, this is subjective and might differ based on personal preferences and interpretations of the narrative.