“Smile” is a deeply engaging graphic novel penned by the talented Raina Telgemeier.
This book, taking cues from the author’s own experiences, cleverly weaves the trials and tribulations of adolescence with the unique challenge of enduring a significant dental accident.
As the purpose of this review is to provide readers with an insightful analysis of “Smile,” we’ll delve into the storyline, character development, artistic style, and themes that make this book resonate with its audience.
We’ll also examine Raina Telgemeier’s influence on the world of graphic novels, especially those aimed at young readers.
Raina Telgemeier is not only the author but also the illustrator of “Smile,” marking her expertise in both areas.
She has been credited with bringing a surge of popularity to graphic novels intended for younger audiences, particularly those that tackle real-world issues.
In this review, we aim to highlight the nuances that make “Smile” a significant contribution to this genre.
Background of the Author
Raina Telgemeier, born on May 26, 1977, is an American cartoonist whose works primarily focus on young adult graphic novels.
Her distinct storytelling style, combined with her ability to capture the intricacies of youth in her illustrations, has earned her both critical acclaim and a devoted reader base.
Telgemeier’s work is known for its authenticity and relatability, often drawing from her experiences.
In fact, “Smile,” considered one of her seminal works, is a semi-autobiographical story that offers readers a glimpse into the author’s own trials during her middle school years.
The book seamlessly connects with young readers, primarily due to its realistic depiction of adolescent life.
Before “Smile,” Telgemeier worked on adaptations of Ann M. Martin’s “The Baby-Sitters Club” for Scholastic, which was well received and helped cement her place in the young adult graphic novel genre.
These books laid the groundwork for the personal and engaging style that readers would come to associate with Telgemeier.
Her other original graphic novels, such as “Sisters,” “Drama,” and “Ghosts,” have similarly drawn on personal experiences and themes of family, identity, and growing up, solidifying her reputation as a powerful voice in young adult literature.
Summary of “Smile”
“Smile” is a delightful and heartwarming coming-of-age story that takes readers on a journey through the trials and tribulations of early adolescence.
The protagonist is Raina herself, depicted as a sixth-grader in San Francisco.
Her story begins with a simple foot race that takes an unexpected turn when she trips and severely damages her two front teeth.
This accident forms the basis of Raina’s struggles, as it ushers in years of orthodontic surgeries and treatments.
But “Smile” isn’t just about dental disasters.
The book delves into the everyday life of a middle schooler; friendships, crushes, family, and school life; all intricately interwoven with Raina’s dental ordeal.
As the readers progress through the narrative, they get to see Raina’s gradual transformation from an insecure pre-teen to a confident young woman who learns to stand up for herself and accept her unique smile.
The setting of the story is the bustling city of San Francisco during the late ’80s and early ’90s.
The cultural and historical context, including the 1989 earthquake, play a subtle yet vital role in the book, grounding the narrative in a specific time and place.
Analysis and Critique
“Smile” is a rich tapestry of themes and experiences, which largely contribute to its appeal among young readers.
The book explores various themes, such as adolescence and self-discovery, acceptance, and resilience in the face of adversity.
The journey of adolescence and self-discovery is artfully portrayed through Raina’s character.
Her struggles with her physical appearance, especially her teeth, coupled with the challenges of puberty, make her journey relatable to anyone who has navigated the path of growing up.
As she grapples with her insecurities, Raina’s character evolves, ultimately finding confidence and acceptance in her unique identity.
In terms of storytelling technique and narrative style, “Smile” is a graphic novel that adeptly uses its format to its advantage.
The illustrations not only supplement the text but often drive the narrative, offering subtle cues about the characters’ emotions and the changing dynamics between them.
The dialogue is realistically depicted, mirroring the way pre-teens speak and interact, further enhancing the authenticity of the story.
Raina’s character development forms the crux of the narrative.
The readers witness her transformation from an uncertain young girl to a self-assured individual who learns to embrace her unique smile.
The supporting characters, such as her friends and family, are well-drawn out, each playing a crucial role in Raina’s story, providing conflict, support, and growth.
Telgemeier’s artwork deserves special mention.
Her drawing style is appealing and accessible, with a vibrant color palette that adds a layer of depth to the story.
The illustrations play a crucial role in the narrative, often conveying emotions and situations more powerfully than words could.
This interplay between the artwork and the narrative makes “Smile” a compelling read, particularly for those new to the world of graphic novels.
Personal Reflections and Interpretation
“Smile” left a lasting impact on me as a reader.
Its powerful depiction of growing up resonated deeply, serving as a poignant reminder of the ups and downs of adolescence.
This book artfully captures the essence of those years, filled with awkwardness, and insecurity, but also self-discovery.
Raina’s character, with her relatable struggles and triumphs, feels like an old friend, making it easy to root for her.
“Smile” struck a chord with me in the way it portrayed the often unspoken pressures that young individuals face to conform to societal standards of appearance.
Raina’s journey to accept her smile served as a stark reminder of the importance of self-love and self-acceptance, a lesson that’s valuable for readers of all ages.
This theme of acceptance, whether of one’s physical appearance or one’s life circumstances, permeates the entire narrative, rendering a heartfelt depth to the story.
The graphic novel also challenges the notion that childhood and adolescence are carefree and devoid of significant worries.
The portrayal of Raina’s physical and emotional pain associated with her dental trauma serves as a compelling counterargument.
It reaffirms that struggles come in various forms and that they are valid, regardless of one’s age.
Comparisons and Connections
Raina Telgemeier’s “Smile” holds a unique place within the landscape of young adult literature and graphic novels.
Its semi-autobiographical nature lends it a level of authenticity that sets it apart.
It shares the heartfelt honesty found in Telgemeier’s other works, like “Sisters” and “Drama,” but “Smile” stands out due to its brave exploration of very personal physical trauma and its subsequent emotional impacts.
Comparing “Smile” to other graphic novels in the same genre, such as “El Deafo” by Cece Bell, it is evident that these books share a common thread in the way they tackle real-life issues through the lens of a young protagonist.
Both novels do a remarkable job of creating an engaging, emotional narrative that doesn’t shy away from the difficult aspects of their characters’ lives.
However, “Smile” is distinct in its narrative.
It intertwines a personal journey of self-acceptance with a vivid portrayal of adolescent life, creating a tapestry of experiences that is engaging and deeply relatable.
The book’s power lies in its ability to capture the essence of adolescence; the good, the bad, and everything in between; and present it in a format that is accessible and appealing to young readers.
“Smile” is not just a book about a girl and her dental journey; it’s a book about growing up, navigating friendships, dealing with family, and most importantly, learning to love oneself, making it a significant addition to young adult literature.
In the final section of this review, we will summarize our discussion and offer some closing thoughts on the value and impact of “Smile.”
Closing Thoughts
“Smile” by Raina Telgemeier is a remarkably relatable graphic novel that tells a story of resilience, self-discovery, and acceptance.
Through the protagonist’s journey, readers experience the highs and lows of adolescence and the unique struggle of coping with a physical transformation.
This review has highlighted the main themes in the novel, its narrative style, the strikingly vivid illustrations, and the notable character development, particularly of Raina.
It is a standout work in the genre of young adult graphic novels due to its realistic depiction of a young girl’s life and its ability to engage readers of all ages.
In terms of recommendation, “Smile” would appeal to a broad audience.
It’s perfect for young readers who are going through their formative years, grappling with the challenges of growing up.
Adults, too, would find this book engaging as it offers a trip down memory lane, reminding them of their own struggles and triumphs during adolescence.
Moreover, the book would be a great read for anyone interested in graphic novels, given its excellent illustrations and narrative.
Our Rating for “Smile”
Story/Plot: 9/10
“Smile” is a narrative that beautifully captures the essence of adolescence while focusing on a unique physical and emotional journey.
It’s a refreshing deviation from typical young adult storylines, centering around the often overlooked aspects of growing up, like dental health and appearance.
The storyline is relatable and engaging, inviting readers to reminisce about their own experiences of youth.
For these reasons, I give the story a 9 out of 10.
Characters: 9/10
The characters in “Smile” are realistic and well-crafted. Raina, the protagonist, is a fully fleshed-out character with distinct personality traits, strengths, and flaws.
The supporting characters are also well-rounded, each contributing to the story’s depth and progress.
Their relationships and interactions feel genuine, mirroring the complexities of real-life relationships.
Therefore, I’d rate the characterization a 9 out of 10.
Artwork/Illustrations: 10/10
The illustrations in “Smile” deserve nothing less than a perfect score.
Telgemeier’s art style is vibrant and appealing, successfully capturing the emotions and situations within the story.
The illustrations do more than just supplement the text; they drive the narrative forward, often telling more about the characters’ feelings than the dialogue.
The color palette, the facial expressions, and the attention to detail in each panel greatly enhance the reading experience.
Themes: 9/10
“Smile” deals with themes that are central to the human experience, such as acceptance, resilience, and self-discovery.
It addresses these topics with a level of sensitivity and understanding that is both enlightening and comforting.
The way these themes are woven into the narrative makes the book a valuable read, especially for young readers navigating similar life experiences.
Hence, the themes earn a 9 out of 10.
Overall Enjoyment: 9/10
“Smile” is a delightful read that leaves a lasting impression.
It strikes a perfect balance between lightheartedness and emotional depth, providing an engaging reading experience.
The book does a fantastic job of bringing back memories of one’s own adolescence, making it a nostalgic read for many.
Overall, it’s a compelling book that one could easily read multiple times, thus justifying a 9 out of 10 for overall enjoyment.
In conclusion, “Smile” garners a solid overall score of 9.2 out of 10.
It is an excellent graphic novel that appeals to a wide range of readers due to its relatable storytelling, expressive illustrations, and poignant themes.
“Smile” has the power to evoke emotions, encourage empathy, and inspire readers, making it a highly recommended addition to any reader’s bookshelf.
We genuinely hope our comprehensive review has covered everything you were looking for.
You can also read further reviews on Amazon.
Thank you for reading and we hope to see you back here soon!