Sometimes I Lie Book Review
Click Image for Amazon Link

Alice Feeney’s debut novel, “Sometimes I Lie,” is a gripping psychological thriller that entangles readers in a web of truth, deception, and memory.

Before diving into this masterpiece, I had heard quite a buzz in literary circles, with many praising its intricate plot and sophisticated narrative structure.

I must admit, my curiosity was sufficiently piqued, prompting me to delve into its pages.

Now, having experienced Amber’s tumultuous world, I find myself both impressed by Feeney’s prowess and emotionally spent by the journey she led me on.

Plot Summary

Set in the cold corridors of a hospital room, we meet Amber Reynolds, a woman trapped within her own mind.

Though she’s unable to move or speak, her cognitive faculties remain intact, making her a silent observer of the events transpiring around her.

This premise alone is chilling, echoing sentiments reminiscent of films like “Awakenings” but with a more sinister twist.

Amber’s story unfolds through three timelines: “Now,” “Then,” and “Before.”

In “Now,” she is in a coma, trying to piece together the events leading up to her current predicament while simultaneously navigating the haunting reality of her unresponsive state.

The “Then” timeline offers readers a glimpse into the days leading up to her coma, providing context and perhaps clues as to what led to her current state.

Lastly, “Before” delves into diary entries from the late 1990s, shedding light on Amber’s childhood and past traumas, painting a clearer picture of the protagonist’s psyche and relationships.

Through these interwoven narratives, Feeney weaves a tale that is both an exploration of memory’s fickle nature and a suspenseful journey toward an unsettling truth.

As Amber’s past and present collide, the lines between friend and foe blur, leading readers down a path where, much like the title suggests, the truth is often cloaked in deception.

Character Analysis

At the core of “Sometimes I Lie” is its protagonist, Amber Reynolds. From the very onset, she’s both the guiding voice and the enigmatic puzzle.

Amber is a character steeped in layers, each more complex than the last.

As the narrative shifts between timelines, readers witness different facets of her personality, ultimately questioning her reliability as a narrator.

There’s an uncanny duality to Amber that makes her both vulnerable and elusive.

She’s a victim of circumstance, trapped within her own body, and yet her recollections, or lack thereof, keep the readers on their toes.

This delicate balance of sympathy and suspicion towards Amber is what makes her a standout character in the realm of psychological thrillers.

The book is enriched by its cast of secondary characters, each playing a pivotal role in Amber’s life and the unfolding mystery.

Paul, Amber’s husband, is portrayed as a loving partner, but as with many characters in this genre, there’s more beneath the surface.

His interactions with Amber in the “Then” timeline provide crucial insights into their relationship dynamics.

There’s a certain tension that lurks, raising questions about trust and loyalty.

Claire, Amber’s sister, is another enigma.

Their bond, filled with childhood memories, familial love, and an undercurrent of rivalry, is integral to the story.

Claire’s actions and motivations, especially in the “Now” timeline as Amber lies in a coma, are both touching and questionable, further blurring the lines of truth.

Themes and Symbols

“Sometimes I Lie” is a treasure trove of intricate themes, with Truth and Deception taking center stage.

The very title is a testament to this duality, hinting at the murky waters of reality versus perception.

Throughout the book, readers are constantly asked to discern between what’s real and what’s a figment of Amber’s potentially distorted memories.

This theme is especially poignant in today’s age of “fake news” and selective realities, making Feeney’s work all the more relevant.

Memory emerges as another dominant theme.

Amber’s past, particularly her childhood, plays a crucial role in her current predicament.

The fractured way in which these memories are presented mirrors the human tendency to suppress painful events, only to have them resurface in unexpected ways.

Memory’s impermanence and subjectivity become evident as Amber grapples with her recollections, leading readers to ponder the reliability of their own memories.

Lastly, Betrayal and Trust are tightly woven into the story’s fabric. Relationships, whether familial or romantic, are tested.

Trust, once broken, casts shadows of doubt, and Feeney masterfully exploits this, leading to heightened suspense.

The intricate relationships, underlined by trust dynamics, serve as the backbone of this psychological thriller, making readers question their own beliefs about trust.

Narrative Structure and Writing Style

Feeney’s “Sometimes I Lie” is nothing short of a structural marvel.

The narrative effortlessly flits between the “Now,” “Then,” and “Before” timelines, yet it maintains a cohesion that’s impressive for such a layered plot.

The use of these alternating timelines not only adds to the suspense but also offers a comprehensive understanding of Amber’s character arc.

It’s like piecing together a jigsaw puzzle where each timeline provides different pieces, and as they start to fit together, a clearer yet more complex image emerges.

Feeney’s prose is both haunting and evocative.

Her choice of words, her sentence structures, and her pacing is brilliantly attuned to the psychological landscape of the story.

She has a knack for creating an ambiance that is simultaneously eerie and intimate.

For instance, the clinical, cold descriptions of the hospital are juxtaposed against Amber’s fervent inner monologues, creating a vivid contrast that engulfs the reader.

The simplicity of her language at times is misleading, for beneath it lies a labyrinth of emotions and mysteries.

Perhaps one of the most commendable aspects of the book is the choice of an unreliable narrator.

This isn’t a new tool in the world of psychological thrillers, but Feeney manages to give it a fresh spin.

Amber’s possible unreliability doesn’t just serve as a plot device; it’s an embodiment of the book’s central themes.

This narrative choice makes readers not just passive consumers of the story, but active participants, constantly trying to discern reality from deception.

Strengths and Weaknesses

Every novel, no matter how well-crafted, has its strengths and potential shortcomings. “Sometimes I Lie” is a testament to Feeney’s literary prowess, and its strengths are manifold.

The intricate, suspense-laden plot stands out, with its unexpected twists and turns keeping readers on the edge of their seats.

Additionally, the deep psychological insights provided, especially through Amber, offer a raw look into the human psyche, making it a tantalizing read for those fascinated by the complexities of the human mind.

However, the novel is not without its weaknesses.

For some readers, the constant shift between timelines might come off as disorienting rather than engaging.

It requires one to be continuously alert and piecing together information, which might not be everyone’s cup of tea.

Also, there are moments in the narrative where certain revelations or character motivations might seem a tad forced or unconvincing, slightly marring the otherwise seamless flow of the story.

Comparisons with Other Works

“Sometimes I Lie” is not alone in its genre of twisting psychological thrillers, but it certainly has carved its niche.

One might find echoes of Gillian Flynn’s “Gone Girl” in the way Feeney crafts her unreliable narrators and entwines truth with deception.

Both novels delve deep into the psyches of their protagonists, revealing dark and unsettling facets of human relationships.

However, where Flynn’s tale is steeped in marital machinations, Feeney leans more into familial bonds and personal traumas.

There are also shades of Paula Hawkins’ “The Girl on the Train” in “Sometimes I Lie”, especially in the way both novels play with memory and perception.

The fragmented, often unreliable memories of the protagonists in both books serve not just as plot devices, but as central themes that push readers to question their understanding of reality.

Yet, despite these similarities, Feeney’s novel stands apart in its execution.

Its unique blend of suspense with deep psychological introspection, combined with its innovative narrative structure, gives it an edge, making it a must-read for fans of the genre but also presenting something refreshingly different.

Personal Reflection

My journey through “Sometimes I Lie” was nothing short of a roller coaster.

There were moments I found myself holding my breath, engrossed in Amber’s experiences, and trying to decipher the tangled web of truths and lies.

This wasn’t just a book; it was an experience.

The narrative often made me reflect on the nature of memories in my own life, their reliability, and how they shape our personal narratives.

One particularly stormy evening, with the book in hand, I found myself deeply engrossed in Amber’s childhood memories.

It made me travel down my memory lane, recollecting moments from my own past that I’d forgotten or perhaps chosen to forget. It’s rare for a book to evoke such personal introspection, and for that, I am grateful to Feeney.

Moreover, the bond between Amber and Claire reminded me of my relationship with my own sibling.

The intricacies, the love, the unsaid feelings, and the subtle rivalries; all felt eerily familiar.

While I’ve never faced the kind of turmoil the characters in the book go through, the exploration of these complex relationships in the novel gave me a new perspective on my own bonds.

Impact and Relevance in Today’s Society

In an age where reality is often mediated through screens and information is continuously filtered through various biases, “Sometimes I Lie” serves as a timely commentary on truth, memory, and self-perception.

Amber’s struggle with deciphering her own reality mirrors the challenges many face in today’s digital age.

We’re constantly bombarded with narratives; some true, some fabricated, and sifting through them to find our own truth can be daunting.

Feeney also taps into the deeply personal realm of mental health.

In a society that’s slowly waking up to the nuances of mental well-being, the novel’s exploration of trauma, memory, and the subsequent impact on one’s psyche is incredibly relevant.

The delicate portrayal of Amber’s emotional landscape offers readers a chance to empathize with the struggles of those battling their own minds and memories.

Moreover, the book delves deep into the intricacies of familial and marital relationships, exploring themes of trust, betrayal, and loyalty.

In a world where relationships are often tested by external influences and internal conflicts, “Sometimes I Lie” holds up a mirror, prompting readers to reflect on their own bonds and the secrets they harbor.

Concluding Thoughts

As I turned the last page of “Sometimes I Lie,” a cocktail of emotions swirled within me; awe, satisfaction, and a tinge of melancholy.

Alice Feeney has crafted a tale that’s both a thrilling roller coaster and a profound exploration of the human psyche.

It’s not just a book; it’s a journey, one that takes you through the labyrinth of the human mind, challenging perceptions at every twist and turn.

While the novel is undeniably a masterclass in suspense and narrative structure, its true beauty lies in its depth.

It’s not merely a thriller to be consumed and forgotten; it lingers, prompting introspection and conversations long after it’s been read.

For any avid reader looking for a story that both enthralls and resonates, “Sometimes I Lie” is a treasure waiting to be discovered.

However, a word of caution: just like its protagonist Amber, this book has layers, and as you peel them back, be prepared for a journey that will challenge, surprise, and deeply move you.

Our Rating for “Sometimes I Lie”

Plot Intricacy (4.7/5): “Sometimes I Lie” boasts a meticulously woven plot that consistently keeps readers on their toes.

Feeney’s knack for crafting unexpected twists makes the narrative a tantalizing puzzle.

However, the reason for a slightly less-than-perfect score is the occasional convolution that might deter some readers from fully engaging with every twist and turn.

Character Depth (4.5/5): The characters, especially Amber, are layered and multifaceted.

Their complexity adds richness to the narrative, pushing readers to constantly reassess their perceptions.

The minor drawback here is that while the primary characters are deeply fleshed out, a few secondary characters might come across as slightly underdeveloped, leaving readers wanting a bit more.

Writing Style (4.8/5): Feeney’s prose is both evocative and efficient.

Her ability to set the scene, evoke emotions, and create suspense with her choice of words is remarkable.

The slight deduction stems from occasional moments where the pacing felt uneven, potentially affecting the immersive experience.

Theme Exploration (5/5): This is where “Sometimes I Lie” truly shines.

The exploration of memory, truth, deception, and the human psyche is masterfully executed.

Feeney doesn’t just skim the surface; she dives deep, making readers reflect on these themes in the context of their own lives.

Emotional Resonance (4.6/5): The novel, with its dark and haunting ambiance, strikes a chord, especially with those who appreciate the psychological depth in their reads.

The journey is an emotional roller coaster, although there might be moments where some readers find it hard to emotionally connect with certain plot developments.

Overall Rating: 4.7/5 “Sometimes I Lie” stands as a testament to Feeney’s storytelling prowess.

It’s a gripping psychological thriller with layers of depth.

While no novel is without its minor imperfections, the strengths of this book far outweigh its weaknesses, making it a highly recommended read for both fans of the genre and those new to it.