Treasure Island Book Review
Click Image for Amazon Link

“Treasure Island,” penned by Robert Louis Stevenson, is not just a tale of pirates, adventures, and buried gold.

It’s a literary voyage that has captivated readers for generations, tugging at the hearts of both the young and the old.

When I first delved into the pages of this novel, I was a mere child, eager for tales of the high seas and swashbuckling heroes.

Yet, revisiting it as an adult, I found layers of complexity and meaning that I had previously missed.

The book stands as a testament to Stevenson’s ability to weave a narrative that is both thrilling and deep, easily accessible to a young reader while still holding profound insights for the more mature.

It is this universal appeal that has cemented “Treasure Island” as a cornerstone in the world of classic literature.


To truly appreciate “Treasure Island,” it’s essential to understand the man behind it.

Robert Louis Stevenson, born in 1850 in Edinburgh, Scotland, was a man constantly in search of adventure.

Plagued by ill health throughout his life, Stevenson sought solace in the world of stories, both reading and writing them.

His travels across Europe and later to the Pacific Islands provided him with the diverse backdrops for many of his tales, but it was his innate ability to understand the human spirit that made his works resonate.

“Treasure Island” was initially serialized in a children’s magazine from 1881 to 1882 under the title “The Sea Cook: A Story for Boys.”

Its immediate success led to its publication as a book in 1883.

Readers of the time were captivated by Stevenson’s portrayal of piracy, an occupation that was simultaneously dreaded and romanticized.

His detailed, almost journalistic style of writing brought the world of buccaneers and buried treasure to vivid life, a world that was long gone but lived again on his pages.

The 19th century was an era of exploration and empire, and “Treasure Island” fit right into the zeitgeist of the age.

But more than that, Stevenson tapped into a more primal human desire: the thirst for adventure and the allure of the unknown.

Even today, in an age of digital maps and GPS, there remains a part of the human soul that yearns for uncharted territories and the thrill of discovery, and “Treasure Island” speaks to that very part.


In the heart of “Treasure Island” is the captivating tale of a boy named Jim Hawkins.

Beginning in a quiet English inn run by Jim’s family, our story takes an intriguing turn with the arrival of a mysterious old sailor known as Billy Bones.

As Jim soon discovers, this sailor possesses a peculiar map, one that points the way to a hidden treasure on a distant, uncharted island.

Upon the demise of Billy Bones and after a brush with some unsavory characters who are after the same map, Jim, alongside trusted adults like Dr. Livesey and Squire Trelawney, embarks on a daring sea expedition aboard the Hispaniola.

Unknown to our protagonists, among their crew is a gang of pirates, led by the charismatic yet cunning one-legged Long John Silver.

The journey to the island is filled with suspense, deception, and alliances.

The lines between friends and foes blur as betrayals are unveiled, climaxing in a race to the treasure and a battle for survival.

Throughout the story, the characters are tested not just by external challenges but by their own morality, desires, and fears.

Themes and Analysis

Stevenson’s “Treasure Island” is not just a riveting tale of adventure but also a study of the duality of human nature, the age-old battle between good and evil, and the gray areas in between.

Dual Nature of Humanity: The character of Long John Silver perfectly encapsulates this duality.

At times, he’s an almost fatherly figure to Jim, providing counsel and care. Yet, he’s also the mastermind behind the mutiny, a man who wouldn’t hesitate to resort to treachery for personal gain.

Through Silver and other characters, Stevenson questions if anyone is wholly good or evil, or if circumstances, desires, and choices shape our nature.

Adventure and Romance of the High Seas: The sea, in its vastness, holds both the promise of fortune and the threat of doom.

“Treasure Island” capitalizes on this allure, drawing readers into the mesmerizing world of sailors, storms, and secrets.

It’s a world where destiny can change with the wind, where loyalty can be as fickle as the tides, and where the call of adventure can drown the voice of reason.

Morality of Piracy and Treachery: Pirates, often romanticized in tales, are shown in a different light here.

While they seek freedom and riches, their path is also stained with blood and betrayal.

This raises questions about the real cost of fortune and whether the ends can ever justify the means.

Coming-of-Age: At the heart of this swashbuckling tale is Jim Hawkins’ journey from innocence to experience.

Through trials and triumphs, Jim learns about trust, bravery, and the often blurred line between right and wrong.

His evolution from a sheltered boy to a seasoned adventurer mirrors the reader’s own journey through the layers of the story.

Character Analysis

Jim Hawkins: The young protagonist of our tale, Jim Hawkins, serves as the reader’s lens into the chaotic, thrilling world of piracy and treasure hunting. At the story’s commencement, Jim is portrayed as an impressionable boy, sheltered by the comforting confines of the Admiral Benbow Inn. But as the narrative unfolds, so does Jim’s character. Encounters with greed, betrayal, and danger compel him to mature rapidly. His courage is tested, his moral compass is challenged, and his understanding of the world is continuously redefined. By the end, Jim emerges not just as a treasure-seeker but as a young man who has learned the values of loyalty, discernment, and resilience.

Long John Silver: Arguably one of literature’s most intriguing antagonists, Long John Silver is a masterclass in complexity.

His one-legged gait and parrot companion make him an unmistakable figure, yet it’s his multifaceted personality that truly captivates readers.

Silver is neither the stereotypical treacherous pirate nor the archetypal mentor; he oscillates between these roles, often leaving readers and characters second-guessing his true intentions.

His interactions with Jim are particularly telling, showcasing a genuine affection that contrasts starkly with his underlying schemes.

This dichotomy serves as a reminder of the unpredictable nature of people and the intricate dance of morality and ambition.

Captain Flint: While Captain Flint never appears in the present narrative, his specter looms large.

The parrot’s frequent squawks of “Pieces of eight!” echo Flint’s legacy, and the very treasure that drives the plot is a testament to his cunning and ruthlessness.

Flint’s posthumous influence underscores the novel’s themes of legacy, reputation, and the long shadow that one’s deeds, for better or worse, can cast.

Others: Supporting characters like Dr. Livesey, Squire Trelawney, and Ben Gunn are instrumental in moving the plot forward and enriching the novel’s universe.

Dr. Livesey’s steady reasoning contrasts with Squire Trelawney’s impulsive nature, offering a balanced approach to the quest.

Ben Gunn’s transformation from a crewman to a marooned, half-mad castaway and finally to a redeemed man showcases the human spirit’s adaptability and the redeeming power of second chances.

Stevenson’s Writing Style

Robert Louis Stevenson’s narrative in “Treasure Island” is remarkable in its evocativeness and pacing. Here are some distinct elements:

Vivid Imagery and Description: Stevenson’s depictions of settings from the Admiral Benbow Inn’s cozy confines to the eerie, untamed landscapes of the island are painted with such meticulous detail that they spring to life in the reader’s imagination.

His descriptions of the sea, in its tempestuous rage or calm serenity, transport readers right onto the deck of the Hispaniola.

Pacing and Tension-building: The ebb and flow of the story’s intensity are masterfully controlled by Stevenson.

Moments of quiet reflection or camaraderie are interspersed with high-stakes chases, battles, and confrontations.

This rhythm ensures that readers remain engaged, their pulse often racing in tandem with the unfolding events.

Dialogue and Dialect: One of Stevenson’s most notable achievements in the novel is his use of authentic dialects, especially in the speech of the pirates.

Their lingo, punctuated by nautical jargon and old sailor idioms, lends an undeniable authenticity to the narrative.

This not only deepens the immersion but also enhances the characterization, making figures like Long John Silver all the more memorable.

Impact and Legacy

“Treasure Island” isn’t just a story; it’s an institution.

Since its inception in the late 19th century, Stevenson’s masterpiece has profoundly impacted literature and popular culture, shaping our very perceptions of piracy and adventure.

Defining the Pirate Genre: Before Jack Sparrow, Blackbeard, or Captain Hook became household names, there was Long John Silver and his motley crew.

“Treasure Island” defined, if not created, the pirate genre as we know it. Stevenson’s portrayal of pirates with their parrots, peg legs, and the quintessential ‘X marks the spot’ became the gold standard, influencing countless books, movies, and TV shows that followed.

Enduring Popularity: Decades have passed, yet the story remains evergreen.

From its initial release to today, “Treasure Island” has seen numerous adaptations across media.

The tale has been told and retold, each iteration resonating with a new generation, be it through cinema, radio dramas, stage plays, or even animated series.

Influence on Later Literature and Films: Beyond direct adaptations, “Treasure Island” has inspired a myriad of works that borrow elements, themes, or characters.

Its influence can be seen in everything from serious maritime literature to light-hearted children’s stories.

The archetype of the wise yet potentially treacherous mentor, epitomized by Long John Silver, has been explored and reinvented in countless narratives.

Timeless Nature: Why does “Treasure Island” continue to captivate?

Perhaps because it speaks to the eternal adventurer in all of us.

In an age where the world is at our fingertips, the tale reminds us of the thrill of the unknown, the allure of discovery, and the complexities of human nature that are as relevant today as they were in Stevenson’s time.

Personal Reflection

My journey with “Treasure Island” began on a rainy afternoon, tucked away in a corner of a dimly lit library.

The spine of the book, worn from countless hands before mine, promised an escape, and oh, what an escape it was!

From the first page, I was transported from my quiet corner to the bustling world of Jim Hawkins.

As a child, the story was an adventure, pure and simple.

The mutinies, the chases, the buried treasure, they were chapters of thrill.

Revisiting it as an adult, however, I found a new appreciation. Now, it wasn’t just an adventure; it was a study of character dynamics, moral ambiguities, and the gray areas of right and wrong.

Long John Silver, whom I once viewed as the quintessential villain, now emerged as a complex character, challenging my perceptions of morality.

Jim Hawkins’ evolution mirrored my own journey from naivety to understanding.

The island, which once was just a backdrop for treasure hunts, now symbolized the larger world, filled with perils, surprises, and lessons.

In the tapestry of literature that has shaped me, “Treasure Island” stands out not just as a story but as an experience, a voyage that I’ve embarked on time and again, each journey revealing new horizons.

Comparisons with Other Works

“Treasure Island,” while distinct in its essence, inevitably draws parallels with other great works of literature, both from Stevenson’s contemporaries and those that followed.

Here’s how it stands in relation to a few notable tales:

“Moby Dick” by Herman Melville: While “Treasure Island” is a tale of adventure and buried treasure, “Moby Dick” delves deep into the obsession of Captain Ahab with the elusive white whale.

Both novels, set against the vast backdrop of the sea, deal with themes of obsession, the nature of good and evil, and the fragility of human life.

However, while Melville’s work is denser, steeped in symbolism and metaphor, Stevenson’s is more accessible, especially to younger readers.

“The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn” by Mark Twain: Both stories present a coming-of-age narrative, albeit in different settings.

Jim Hawkins and Huck Finn are young boys exposed to the broader, often dangerous world, learning life’s lessons firsthand.

While Jim grapples with pirates and the lure of treasure, Huck wrestles with societal norms, racism, and his own evolving moral compass.

“Peter Pan” by J.M. Barrie: Captain Hook, the antagonist in Barrie’s play (and later novel), seems to be in direct dialogue with Stevenson’s pirates, especially in terms of characterization and setting.

Both Neverland and Treasure Island are places of danger and wonder, shaping the young protagonists’ views of the world.

Yet, while “Treasure Island” ventures into the complexities of morality, “Peter Pan” is a poignant reflection on the fleeting nature of childhood.

“The Odyssey” by Homer: One of the foundational adventure epics, “The Odyssey” chronicles Odysseus’ ten-year journey home after the fall of Troy.

The challenges he faces from seductive sirens to cyclopes can be seen as ancient analogs to Jim’s encounters.

Both tales underscore the theme that the journey itself is as valuable, if not more so, than the destination or treasure.

Closing Thoughts

After sailing through the pages of “Treasure Island,” one thing becomes clear: this isn’t just a novel; it’s a rite of passage.

A journey through the tumultuous seas of adolescence, a reflection on the duality of man, and an exhilarating treasure hunt, all rolled into one.

The characters, especially Jim Hawkins and Long John Silver, stay with you long after the final page.

Their choices, dilemmas, and the lessons they learn are universally relatable.

Stevenson’s deft handling of such a layered narrative, making it engaging for both children and adults, is commendable.

However, this isn’t just a book for those seeking adventure. It’s also for those who love introspection, who ponder about right and wrong, loyalty, and betrayal.

It’s for readers who appreciate the nuances of human nature and the ever-present gray areas in our moral landscape.

Would I recommend “Treasure Island”?

Without a doubt. Whether you’re a young reader eager for a swashbuckling adventure or an adult revisiting childhood favorites, this book offers a rich, rewarding experience.

So, hoist the anchor, set sail, and let Stevenson guide you to the hidden treasures within its pages and within yourself.

Our Rating for “Treasure Island”

After navigating through the thrilling narrative, unforgettable characters, and profound themes of “Treasure Island,” it’s time to anchor our thoughts and assess the book’s overall merit.

Here’s an in-depth look at the various aspects that contribute to the final rating:

Plot: 9/10 The story’s design, with its twists and turns, makes “Treasure Island” an unputdownable read.

Stevenson’s handling of the plot ensures that the tension is maintained throughout, with enough surprises to keep readers engaged.

Though some might find certain plot points predictable, they don’t diminish the overall enjoyment.

Characters: 9.5/10 Jim Hawkins and Long John Silver are not merely characters; they become acquaintances, leading the reader through a maze of human emotions and moral dilemmas.

The depth of their portrayals, along with the robust supporting cast, adds layers of complexity to the story.

These are characters that linger, long after the book is closed.

Writing Style: 8.5/10 Stevenson’s descriptive prowess shines in “Treasure Island.”

His ability to evoke imagery and mood is exceptional.

The dialogues, particularly the pirate dialects, add authenticity. However, some readers may find certain passages heavy on nautical terms, making them slightly challenging to follow.

Themes: 9/10 The themes explored in “Treasure Island” elevate it from a mere adventure tale to a philosophical journey.

The novel dives into morality, loyalty, greed, and the coming-of-age experience, offering reflections that resonate across age groups.

Impact and Legacy: 10/10 Few books have shaped a genre and left a cultural imprint like “Treasure Island.”

Its impact on literature, media, and even our collective imagination of pirates is unparalleled.

The novel’s endurance testifies to its timeless appeal.

Accessibility: 8/10 While the story is engaging and the characters relatable, the novel’s use of archaic language and specialized nautical terms might be a barrier for some readers, particularly younger ones.

Personal Enjoyment: 9.5/10 My own journey with “Treasure Island” has been a delightful one.

It’s a book that I’ve returned to, discovering new facets each time.

The adventure, the characters, and the underlying wisdom make it a rewarding read.

Overall Rating: 9.1/10

“Treasure Island” is more than a novel; it’s an experience.

It caters to the child in all of us who yearns for adventure and the adult who seeks deeper understanding.

While it may have minor shortcomings in accessibility, they do little to mar the overall richness of the experience.

Whether you’re discovering it for the first time or revisiting it as an old friend, “Treasure Island” is a literary treasure in itself.

It’s not just a book you read; it’s a world you inhabit, a journey you embark upon, and a life lesson you absorb.

A must-read for adventurers, dreamers, and thinkers alike.