Without Merit Book Review
Click Image for Amazon Link

Colleen Hoover, a name resonant in the echelons of contemporary fiction, consistently offers readers an intimate glimpse into the complex realm of relationships, emotions, and the human psyche.

From her debut, “Slammed,” to her later works, Hoover’s novels are a mirror to the intricacies of love, life, and all the grey areas in between. “Without Merit” is no exception.

The novel takes readers into the labyrinthine world of the Voss family, providing a stark, unvarnished perspective on life within a seemingly dysfunctional family.

Yet, as is the magic of Hoover, the story doesn’t dwell on the dysfunctional but rather searches for and often finds the threads of love, understanding, and redemption hidden within the chaos.

Summary of the Book (No Major Spoilers)

Set in a dilapidated church in a small Texan town, “Without Merit” unravels the life of the Voss family, which is anything but conventional.

We see this world through the eyes of Merit Voss, a teenager who feels like the odd one out, even within her quirky family.

She holds a trophy collection of others’ mistakes, quite literally, and struggles to find her voice among the myriad of secrets, resentments, and unsaid emotions that saturate the household.

Merit, often disillusioned with her family members’ actions, believes she is surrounded by hypocrisy.

From her mother who lives in the basement to her father’s new wife, Victoria (strangely, the exact lookalike of her mother), living above ground, to her brother Utah’s enigmatic behavior, the list is extensive.

Add in Merit’s twin sister, Honor, whose obsession with terminally ill individuals takes quirky to a whole new level, and you have a household teetering on the brink of emotional chaos.

Yet, as much as Merit feels like the observer of her family’s oddities, she’s hiding secrets of her own.

Enter Sagan, a boy Merit meets and immediately feels a connection with, only to find out he’s off-limits in the most unexpected way.

The narrative masterfully weaves through these intricacies, revealing the layers of each character, their fears, hopes, and the reasons behind their peculiar actions.

“Without Merit” is a journey into recognizing that often, the face one presents to the world masks a tumult of emotions and secrets, and sometimes, salvation comes from the most unexpected places.

Main Characters and Development:

At the heart of “Without Merit” lies a constellation of characters, each complex and uniquely flawed, making them remarkably human and relatable.

Merit Voss is the lens through which we peer into this tumultuous world.

She’s not just a teenager navigating the usual tribulations of adolescence but also a young woman grappling with a sense of isolation within her own home.

As the story unfolds, Merit’s external cynicism and internal vulnerabilities become evident.

What’s most commendable is how Hoover charts her growth.

From her initial feelings of being an outsider, even in her family, to eventually finding her voice, Merit’s journey is raw, authentic, and deeply poignant.

Her twin, Honor, serves as an interesting counterpoint.

With an unusual obsession with befriending those on the cusp of death, Honor’s character is a blend of eccentricity and profound sensitivity.

Her actions, although bizarre at times, provide an exploration into the realm of mortality and the human need for connection.

Utah, their elder brother, is another enigma.

At first glance, his role might seem peripheral, but as layers are peeled back, his significance, struggles, and secrets become central to the narrative, offering a broader view of the Voss family dynamics.

Sagan is the unexpected catalyst. He’s not just a romantic interest for Merit but also a mirror that reflects her vulnerabilities and strengths.

Their interactions are charged with an intensity that oscillates between passion and profound introspection.

Themes Explored

Hoover’s “Without Merit” isn’t just a story; it’s a tapestry of themes interwoven with dexterity.

Family Dynamics stands at the forefront.

The Voss family isn’t your typical unit, and their unconventional setting, a converted church, further accentuates their idiosyncrasies.

Through the highs and lows, the novel makes a profound statement; every family has its dysfunctions, but it’s the love and bond that can help navigate through the chaos.

Mental Health is a pivotal theme, approached with sensitivity and depth.

From subtle hints to direct confrontations, the narrative underscores the importance of addressing mental health, seeking help, and the impacts of ignoring or trivializing it.

Love and Relationships are explored not just in the romantic sense, but also in the context of familial ties.

Hoover dives deep into the complexities of affection, loyalty, betrayal, and redemption.

The relationships, with their myriad shades, highlight that love isn’t just about grand gestures but often found in the smallest, most unexpected moments.

Lastly, Self-Discovery is a journey undertaken not just by Merit but other characters as well.

The realization of one’s worth, confronting one’s demons, and the pursuit of authenticity are themes that resonate throughout the narrative, making it a deeply introspective read.

Writing Style and Narrative Technique

Colleen Hoover has carved a niche for herself in the realm of contemporary fiction, and “Without Merit” serves as a testament to her distinctive voice.

Her writing is immersive, often pulling readers into the very heartbeat of her characters.

In “Without Merit”, the first-person narrative is a deliberate choice, allowing us to deeply connect with Merit’s internal world.

We are privy to her thoughts, frustrations, and moments of epiphany, making the reading experience profoundly personal.

Hoover’s prose is at once sharp and poetic, making even the everyday moments come alive with emotion.

The dialogue is snappy, genuine, and often laced with humor, a technique that makes heavy moments digestible and offers relief.

Hoover also displays her gift of pacing.

The story flows effortlessly, with each chapter urging the reader to delve deeper into the Voss family’s world.

By weaving in flashbacks and introspective moments without disrupting the narrative flow, she ensures that readers are provided with rich backstories and context.

Strengths of the Novel

“Without Merit” is not just a tale; it’s an experience, and several strengths make it stand out.

Character Depth: One of Hoover’s unparalleled strengths is her ability to craft characters that are multi-faceted and deeply human.

They are flawed, yet relatable, allowing readers to see bits of themselves or people they know in each character.

Their authentic struggles make the emotional arcs believable and compelling.

Tackling Tough Themes: Hoover doesn’t shy away from the heavier aspects of life.

Whether it’s mental health, family dysfunction, or the journey of self-acceptance, she handles each theme with a deftness and sensitivity that’s commendable.

She challenges her readers to think, introspect, and sometimes even confront their own biases or beliefs.

Engaging Plot: The narrative isn’t linear or predictable.

Hoover masterfully introduces twists and turns, some subtle and others more pronounced, ensuring readers remain invested from start to finish.

Emotional Resonance: This is a book that evokes emotions.

From heartbreak to joy, from frustration to understanding, readers are taken on a roller-coaster, making the narrative stick long after the last page has been turned.

Criticisms or Points of Contention

No piece of literature is without its critics, and while “Without Merit” shines in many aspects, there are certain elements that might not sit well with every reader.

Drama Overload: One potential criticism could be the heightened drama that envelops the Voss family.

Some readers might feel that the accumulation of so many quirks, secrets, and revelations in one household stretches the boundaries of believability.

While this intensity drives the plot, there are moments where the dramatic weight could feel overbearing.

Character Decisions: At times, the choices and actions of certain characters might seem impulsive or poorly motivated.

This could lead to moments where readers may find it hard to empathize or understand the driving force behind certain decisions.

Romantic Elements: While the budding relationship between Merit and Sagan is central to the narrative, some might feel it borders on the clichéd “young love” trope, with its inherent intensity and complications.

Others might argue that their relationship, though profound in places, sometimes overshadows the deeper familial and personal themes that the book seeks to address.

Comparison with Hoover’s Other Works

For those familiar with Colleen Hoover’s expansive bibliography, “Without Merit” sits comfortably among her best, yet it also stands distinct in its thematic choices and narrative structure.

Emotional Depth: Similar to her other novels like “It Ends With Us” and “Ugly Love”, Hoover crafts a narrative replete with emotional depth in “Without Merit”.

However, where some of her novels focus primarily on romantic relationships, this one delves deeper into family dynamics, making it unique in its emotional range.

Character Complexity: “Hopeless” and “November 9” showcased Hoover’s ability to create characters that are both lovable and deeply flawed.

This signature touch is evident in “Without Merit”, but with an added layer, the ensemble of the Voss family.

It’s a larger cast, each member intricately detailed, showcasing her evolution as a writer.

Thematic Choices: “Without Merit” stands out for its daring exploration of mental health, family dysfunction, and the trials of adolescence.

While other books like “Confess” or “All Your Perfects” touch upon personal trials and tribulations, none dive as deep into the tumultuous waters of familial relationships as this one.

Significance in Contemporary Literature:

In an era where contemporary literature is often a reflection of society’s evolving norms, values, and challenges, “Without Merit” firmly plants its feet as a significant work. Here’s why:

Refreshing Honesty: At a time when many novels often romanticize or skirt around the complexities of familial ties, Hoover’s portrayal of the Voss family is unapologetically honest.

By presenting their imperfections and vulnerabilities without judgment, she brings to the forefront the idea that every family, in its own unique way, is both broken and beautiful.

Mental Health Advocacy: Mental health has gradually become a focal point in literature, and rightly so. Yet, Hoover’s approach is nuanced.

Instead of grand moments of revelation, she chooses the subtle, day-to-day battles, making the narrative not just relatable but also an important advocacy tool.

In an age where mental health discussions are crucial, “Without Merit” stands as a testament to the importance of understanding, empathy, and dialogue.

Redefining Young Adult Tropes: While the novel sits comfortably in the Young Adult genre, it challenges many of its established tropes.

Merit’s journey is not just about teenage angst or first love.

It’s about self-identity, familial bonds, and the weight of secrets, making it relevant not just for young adults but readers across age groups.

Closing Thoughts

Reading “Without Merit” is akin to embarking on an emotional odyssey.

There were moments of sheer heartbreak, interspersed with instances of unexpected humor and profound realizations.

As I navigated the corridors of the converted church that the Voss family calls home, it became more than just a novel, it transformed into a mirror reflecting our own insecurities, hopes, and unspoken words.

What stands out is Hoover’s ability to craft characters that linger, long after the last page is turned. Merit, with her resilience, became a beacon of hope.

The Voss family, in all its chaos, became a reminder that love, in its many forms, is what binds us together.

In the grand tapestry of contemporary literature, “Without Merit” is not just a story; it’s an experience.

An experience that prompts introspection, sparks dialogue, and most importantly, fosters a deep sense of empathy.

For anyone on the brink of exploring the complexities of family, love, and personal growth, this novel is not just recommended; it’s essential.

Our Rating for “Without Merit”

In the realm of book reviews, providing a rating often encapsulates the overall experience of the reader. With “Without Merit”, my verdict stands at a commendable 4.5 out of 5 stars.

Here’s a deep dive into why:

Strengths That Elevated the Score:

Rich Character Development: One of the pivotal strengths of “Without Merit” is Hoover’s deft handling of characters.

The multi-dimensional nature of Merit, Sagan, Honor, and the rest of the Voss family makes them leap off the pages, allowing readers to immerse themselves fully in their world.

Thematic Depth: The way Hoover grapples with mental health, self-identity, and the intricate dance of family dynamics is both poignant and refreshing.

These themes resonate in today’s world, making the novel timely and significant.

Narrative Flow: The pacing and structure of the story are commendable.

It’s a book that’s hard to put down, and that’s not just because of the plot twists, but because of the emotional cadence Hoover establishes.

Minor Hiccups That Hindered a Full 5 Stars:

Potential Over-Dramatization: At certain junctures, the intensity of drama in the Voss family’s life felt a touch overboard.

While it heightened the reading experience, there were moments where it treaded the thin line of becoming melodramatic.

Predictable Romantic Arcs: While the budding relationship between Merit and Sagan offered numerous heartfelt moments, there were instances where their narrative arc felt somewhat predictable, echoing familiar tropes of young adult romance.

In conclusion, a 4.5-star rating feels apt for “Without Merit”.

While no novel is beyond criticism, the strengths of this book vastly overshadow its minor imperfections.

It’s a literary journey that engages, challenges, and ultimately, uplifts.

For readers seeking a tale that marries emotion with depth, this comes highly recommended.

To sum it up, “Without Merit” stands as a shining beacon in contemporary literature, its minor flaws merely underscoring its authenticity and heart.

A 4.5 out of 5 is not just a rating; it’s an acknowledgment of a tale well told.