You Book Review

Set amidst the bustling streets of New York City, “You” presents a chilling narrative woven by Caroline Kepnes.

It’s not just a book; it’s a descent into the abyss of obsession in the age of social media.

Right from the get-go, the novel feels like a fresh, albeit disturbing, take on modern-day romance and the blurred lines between love and fixation.

At the heart of this novel stands Joe Goldberg, an ordinary bookseller with an extraordinary obsession.

To an outsider, Joe may seem like a typical guy, someone you’d pass by on a busy street without a second glance.

Yet, Kepnes draws us into the intricate web of his mind, letting us in on the darker alleys of his thoughts, which are anything but ordinary.

The book masterfully situates itself in a unique niche, a blend of a psychological thriller dripping with elements of contemporary romance.

However, this is no fairy tale, and there’s no knight in shining armor. Instead, there’s a man armed with the internet and an unwavering conviction in his version of ‘love’.

Plot Overview (No Major Spoilers)

“You” is less of a ‘whodunit’ and more of a ‘why-he-did-it’.

We see through the eyes of Joe as he stumbles upon Guinevere Beck or Beck, as she prefers.

An innocent interaction at the bookstore Joe works at becomes the catalyst for an ever-deepening obsession.

While many romantic tales begin with a chance meeting, what sets this one apart is the sinister undertone that accompanies Joe’s every thought and action.

From the very beginning, the line between infatuation and stalking begins to blur.

Beck’s very public social media profiles become Joe’s windows, not just into her daily life, but into her thoughts, fears, desires, and secrets.

The digital breadcrumbs she unwittingly leaves behind guide Joe’s pursuit, making us, as readers, question our own digital footprints.

The lengths Joe goes to in order to become an irreplaceable part of Beck’s life are both shocking and disconcertingly methodical.

Whether it’s manipulating situations or removing obstacles (read: people) from Beck’s life, Joe’s determination knows no bounds.

Yet, it’s crucial to note that the narrative isn’t purely about Joe’s pursuit.

Kepnes provides glimpses into Beck’s life, making her more than just an object of desire.

Beck, herself, is a layered character, with dreams, vulnerabilities, and flaws that play an integral role in the story’s unfolding.

Throughout the plot, the omnipresent role of technology is undeniable.

Joe uses it not as a tool of convenience but as a weapon of intimacy.

It becomes a silent accomplice in his quest, raising unsettling questions about privacy, security, and the digital age’s very nature.

Writing Style & Pacing

Kepnes’ choice to write “You” in the second person is nothing short of brilliant, creating an intimacy (or, perhaps more aptly, an intrusiveness) that is unparalleled.

Every “you” uttered by Joe, directed at Beck, feels eerily like it’s meant for us, the readers.

We’re trapped in the claustrophobic confines of Joe’s mind, privy to every twisted thought, every rationalization.

It’s disconcerting, to say the least.

The writing itself is raw and unfiltered.

Kepnes doesn’t sugarcoat Joe’s thoughts, nor does she shy away from the brutal honesty of his internal monologues.

The prose is compelling, and at times, you might find yourself feeling a bizarre sympathy for Joe, only to be jolted back into revulsion a few pages later.

This emotional roller coaster is a testament to Kepnes’ mastery of her craft.

The pacing is meticulously constructed.

There are moments of slow-burning tension, where the suspense feels palpable, almost like a character in itself.

These are juxtaposed against bursts of heart-racing action that leave the reader gasping for breath.

The balance ensures that while we have time to ponder Joe’s mindset and motivations, we’re also constantly on our toes, awaiting the next twist.

Character Analysis

Joe Goldberg: Joe is, without a doubt, one of the most complex characters in contemporary literature.

He’s both the protagonist and the antagonist, blurring the lines so masterfully that at times it becomes difficult to pigeonhole him.

There’s a duality to Joe that Kepnes magnificently portrays the seemingly mundane bookseller with an insidious underbelly.

His capacity to justify his actions, no matter how heinous, brings to light the terrifying extent of human self-deception.

Guinevere Beck (Beck): Beck is more than just the subject of Joe’s fixation.

She’s an embodiment of modern vulnerabilities.

A striving writer and a young woman searching for her place in the world, Beck’s own complexities come to the fore throughout the narrative.

Kepnes doesn’t paint her as a mere damsel in distress. She has her flaws, her insecurities, and at times, her own obsessions.

The duality isn’t reserved for Joe alone; Beck too oscillates between being the object of Joe’s desires and a character with depth, agency, and her own narrative arc.

Supporting Characters: Kepnes populates the world of “You” with a cast of memorable secondary characters.

Whether it’s Peach, Beck’s wealthy and manipulative friend with her own set of obsessions, or Benji, Beck’s on-again, off-again boyfriend, each character serves a purpose.

They are not merely props but instead add layers to the story, providing perspectives and challenges that further illuminate the depths of Joe’s psyche.


Obsession and Love: “You” navigates the treacherous waters between love and obsession.

What starts as an infatuation for Joe quickly spirals into a full-blown obsession, challenging our very understanding of love.

Is love supposed to be selfless, or can it manifest as a desperate need to possess and control?

Kepnes doesn’t hand us the answers on a platter but instead lets us stew in the ambiguity, making us question our own relationships and the lengths we might go to protect them.

Technology and Stalking: One of the most chilling aspects of “You” is how it showcases the terrifying ease with which someone can infiltrate another’s life using technology.

From social media to emails, Joe utilizes every tool at his disposal to embed himself deeper into Beck’s life.

Kepnes sounds the alarm on our carefree digital footprint, highlighting the dangers lurking in our online openness.

It’s a theme that resonates deeply in today’s hyper-connected age.

Morality and Justification: The internal moral compass of Joe Goldberg is a fascinating study of human psychology.

Every act, no matter how dark, is accompanied by a self-spun rationale that gives Joe the moral high ground.

This delving into the psychology of justification provides a disturbing glimpse into how the human mind can warp itself to see righteousness in even the darkest of deeds.

Relevance in Modern Society

The Double-Edged Sword of Social Media: The world today is more connected than ever, with social media platforms providing windows into our lives.

While this connectivity can be a source of joy, “You” sheds light on its darker aspects.

The book serves as a stark reminder of how our lives, so openly displayed, can become playgrounds for those with ill intentions.

It compels us to reconsider our online boundaries and the information we freely share.

The Illusion of Perfect Relationships: In a world where curated Instagram posts and picture-perfect relationships are the norm, “You” exposes the underbelly of these seemingly flawless narratives.

Joe and Beck’s relationship, on the surface, could be the envy of many.

But scratch the veneer, and the rot is evident.

Kepnes seems to be nudging us to question our own relationships and the facades we maintain for the world to see.

Digital Privacy and Vulnerabilities: Beyond the personal realm, “You” also touches upon larger societal concerns around data privacy and the ease with which one’s digital identity can be compromised.

It isn’t just about the personal choices we make online but also the systems in place that might allow for these breaches of privacy.

The novel becomes a conversation starter on these pressing issues, urging readers to be more cautious and aware.

Comparative Analysis

A Unique Spin on Psychological Thrillers: Within the broad genre of psychological thrillers, many works delve into the dark crevices of human obsession.

Classics like Stephen King’s “Misery” or Patricia Highsmith’s “The Talented Mr. Ripley” explore the extremes of human fixation.

However, “You” carves out a unique niche by blending this darkness with the modern age’s nuances, notably the digital realm.

Contrast with Romantic Obsession Literature: When compared to tales of romantic obsession such as “Lolita” by Vladimir Nabokov or “Endless Love” by Scott Spencer, “You” feels starkly contemporary.

While those novels tackle obsession with depth and nuance, Kepnes’s work ties it to the digital age’s immediacy and vulnerability, giving it a fresh, perturbing angle.

Modern Narratives on Digital Stalking: Recent literature has started to grapple with the implications of our digital lives, but few do it with the intensity of “You”.

Novels like “The Circle” by Dave Eggers touch on digital privacy concerns and the omnipresence of technology, but Kepnes’s work stands out by personalizing these themes, making them intimate and visceral.

Personal Opinion & Recommendation

Engrossing and Unsettling: Reading “You” is an experience in and of itself.

It’s like being on a roller-coaster, with its high-intensity moments balanced with contemplative dives into human psychology.

Kepnes’s writing style is both engrossing and raw, leaving a lasting impression.

Character Depth: Joe Goldberg is both captivating and horrifying.

Rarely has a character evoked such conflicting emotions; a mix of sympathy, disdain, horror, and at times, begrudging respect for his cunning.

Similarly, Beck isn’t just a plot device or a damsel; she’s a fully fleshed-out character with her own dreams, insecurities, and flaws.

Recommendation: I would wholeheartedly recommend “You” to readers who love deep psychological dives and are prepared to confront the uncomfortable.

It’s a novel that will make you think, reassess, and perhaps even revisit your online habits.

However, a word of caution: it’s not for the faint of heart.

The narrative can be disturbing, and there are moments that may be triggering for some readers.

But if one is willing to venture into its depths, “You” promises a reading experience like no other.

Trigger Warnings: Given the themes of stalking, obsession, and the explicit content at times, potential readers should be aware and gauge their comfort levels before diving in.

The Ending’s Implications & Future Prospects

A Twisted Finale: Without venturing into explicit spoilers, the climax of “You” is a culmination of all the tension, suspense, and moral ambiguity that Kepnes so skillfully weaves throughout the narrative.

The end ties many threads, but also leaves certain questions hauntingly open-ended, allowing readers to form their own conclusions.

Characters’ Arcs: The conclusion sees significant developments in the arcs of both Joe and Beck.

Their dynamics evolve in ways both expected and surprising.

The depth of Joe’s obsession and the consequences it brings to Beck’s life make for a finale that is both shocking and inevitable.

Setting the Stage: While “You” can stand alone as a powerful narrative, the ending also leaves the door ajar for further exploration.

This provides Kepnes with fertile ground for a continuation, which she indeed takes up in the subsequent installment, “Hidden Bodies”.

A Comment on the Inevitability of Obsession: The ending of “You” is not just a culmination of events; it’s a poignant reflection on the nature and trajectory of obsession.

It questions whether such intense fixations can ever find resolution or if they’re doomed to spiral out of control, consuming everything in their path.

Broader Impact & Reception

Critical Acclaim and Scrutiny: “You” was met with a mix of acclaim and scrutiny upon its release.

Critics lauded Kepnes’ fresh voice, the novel’s tense pacing, and its innovative take on the psychological thriller genre.

However, there was also critique, with some arguing that the novel perhaps glamorized stalking and obsessive behavior.

Readers’ Engagement: The book was more than just a commercial success; it spurred discussions on forums, book clubs, and social media.

The themes of digital vulnerability, the nature of modern relationships, and the psychology of obsession resonated deeply with many, making “You” more than just a novel, it became a cultural talking point.

Adaptation to Screen: The popularity and impact of “You” transcended the literary world with its adaptation into a TV series.

This brought the story to an even wider audience, furthering discussions and debates about its themes.

The on-screen portrayal added another layer to the narrative, and the series, much like the book, found a dedicated fanbase while also facing its share of critiques.

Position in Contemporary Literature: “You” has firmly cemented its place in contemporary literature as a work that captures the zeitgeist of the digital age.

Its exploration of modern-day obsessions, coupled with its unique narrative voice, makes it a defining book of its time.

Authorial Intent & Style

A Distinct Narrative Voice: Kepnes’ choice to write “You” in the second person is bold and immersive.

It’s not merely a stylistic decision but a means to pull readers into the narrative, making them complicit in Joe’s actions.

By directly addressing “you” (Beck), Kepnes cleverly blurs the lines between the reader and the object of Joe’s obsession.

Modern Societal Commentary: Through her narrative, Kepnes isn’t just spinning a tale of dark romance; she’s critiquing modern society’s obsessions, our fixation with online personas, our often careless approach to digital privacy, and the superficial nature of many contemporary relationships.

Delving into Dark Psyches: Kepnes doesn’t sanitize or romanticize Joe’s actions.

Instead, she plunges readers deep into the unsettling mind of a stalker.

Through this, she may be urging readers to confront and understand the darker aspects of human psychology, rather than shying away from them.

Balancing Suspense with Depth: While “You” is undeniably thrilling, Kepnes also layers her narrative with moments of introspection and depth, elevating it from a mere page-turner to a thought-provoking exploration of human nature and societal norms.

Broader Conversations Sparked by “You”

Romanticization of Toxic Behaviors: One of the most significant discussions around “You” is the portrayal and potentially inadvertent glamorization of toxic behaviors.

While Joe is a captivating character, his actions are deeply problematic.

This prompted debates on whether the novel and its adaptation may inadvertently normalize or romanticize stalking and obsessive behaviors.

Digital Privacy Concerns: “You” ignited broader conversations about the nature of privacy in the digital age.

It made many readers reconsider their digital footprints, questioning how much personal information they willingly or unwittingly put out in the online realm.

Nature of Modern Relationships: Beyond its thrilling plot, “You” also sparked discussions on the nature of contemporary relationships.

The book explores not just romantic relationships but also friendships and personal connections in an age dominated by digital interactions.

Society’s Role in Shaping Behaviors: Another significant conversation birthed from the novel revolves around society’s role in shaping individual behaviors.

Does our culture, with its relentless focus on curated perfection and online voyeurism, contribute to creating personalities like Joe?

The novel urges readers to consider this challenging question.

The Role of Secondary Characters

Beyond Joe and Beck: While Joe Goldberg and Guinevere Beck are undoubtedly the central figures in “You,” the novel’s richness is further enhanced by its cast of secondary characters.

Each of these characters not only serves to move the plot forward but also offers nuanced insights into the story’s broader themes.

Paco: The young neighbor of Joe, Paco is a symbol of innocence in the midst of a narrative dominated by darkness.

His interactions with Joe shed light on a different, softer side of the protagonist, suggesting the complexities inherent in human nature.

Peach Salinger: Beck’s wealthy and controlling best friend, Peach represents the upper echelons of society and brings in themes of privilege and entitlement.

She also becomes a formidable counterforce to Joe, adding another layer of tension and intrigue to the story.

Her obsession with Beck, although different in nature, mirrors Joe’s, leading readers to question where admiration ends and obsession begins.

Dr. Nicky: As Beck’s therapist, Dr. Nicky provides a professional perspective on her psyche.

However, as the narrative unfolds, his role becomes increasingly complicated, challenging ethical boundaries and further highlighting the theme of obsession.

Benji: Beck’s on-again, off-again boyfriend serves as a foil to Joe.

His relationship with Beck and subsequent interactions with Joe underline the different forms of toxic masculinity and how they manifest in romantic relationships.

Symbolism in “You”

The Bookstore: Mooney’s bookstore, where Joe works, is more than just a backdrop.

In a world dominated by digital interactions, the bookstore stands as a bastion of analog, tactile experiences.

It symbolizes Joe’s desire to connect deeply, in contrast to the shallow, fleeting nature of online connections.

However, the bookstore’s basement, where Joe commits some of his darkest deeds, complicates this symbol, suggesting that even spaces of knowledge and nostalgia can harbor darkness.

The Cage: Found in the bookstore’s basement, the cage is a palpable symbol of Joe’s need to control and possess.

It represents the physical manifestation of his obsession, the lengths he’s willing to go to ensure his desires are met, and the boundaries he’s ready to breach.

Social Media: In “You,” social media is more than a tool; it’s a symbol of modern society’s dual nature.

On one hand, it’s a platform for connection, expression, and exploration. On the other, it’s a realm of curated falsehoods, vulnerabilities, and surveillance.

The Glass Jar of Teeth: Without diving into explicit plot details, this disturbing collection serves as a chilling reminder of Joe’s transgressions.

It symbolizes the tangible remnants of his dark deeds and the weight of his past that he carries with him.

In “You”, every character, setting, and symbol is meticulously crafted to serve the narrative’s greater purpose.

The secondary characters enrich the story, providing various perspectives and adding depth to the themes.

Meanwhile, the symbols employed by Kepnes amplify the narrative’s emotional intensity and further anchor its relevance in the contemporary world.

Every layer of the novel, from the protagonists to the subtlest of symbols, works in harmony to deliver a story that’s both thrilling and thought-provoking.

Comparisons to Other Works

Comparison to Classic Thrillers: “You” shares its core with classic thrillers.

Its suspense-filled narrative, complex characters, and chilling climax echo elements from iconic works like Patricia Highsmith’s “The Talented Mr. Ripley” and Stephen King’s “Misery”.

However, “You” sets itself apart through its unique narrative perspective and its exploration of contemporary societal concerns.

Contemporary Psychological Thrillers: In the landscape of contemporary psychological thrillers, “You” stands alongside works such as “Gone Girl” by Gillian Flynn and “The Girl on the Train” by Paula Hawkins.

They all delve into the darker aspects of relationships and personal obsessions, but “You” distinguishes itself through its second-person narrative and its exploration of the digital age’s nuances.

Comparison to its Sequel “Hidden Bodies”: In comparison to its sequel, “Hidden Bodies”, “You” is arguably more focused on establishing its main character and building the tension in Joe’s relationship with Beck.

“Hidden Bodies” expands on Joe’s character and his psychopathic tendencies while introducing new relationships and settings.

Comparison to its TV Adaptation: The TV adaptation of “You” largely stays faithful to the original material but also takes some creative liberties.

While the show captures the book’s core essence, the reading experience of the novel offers a more in-depth exploration of Joe’s psyche through its immersive narrative voice.

Final Assessment

A Defining Psychological Thriller: “You” is not just a thriller; it’s a sharp societal commentary, a probe into the human psyche, and a disturbing exploration of love and obsession in the digital age.

With its unique narrative style, engrossing plot, and deeply flawed yet compelling characters, “You” has etched its mark as a defining psychological thriller of its time.

Addressing Criticisms: While the book has faced criticism for potentially romanticizing toxic behaviors, it’s crucial to note that Kepnes never excuses or glorifies Joe’s actions.

Instead, she exposes his disturbing mind in all its complexity, urging readers to grapple with uncomfortable realities.

Reflection on Society: “You” is as much a mirror held up to society as it is a work of fiction.

By unraveling a narrative centered around obsession and the digital footprint, Kepnes forces us to reflect on our own online behaviors and the potentially dangerous dynamics they could invite.

A Lasting Impact: The book’s lasting impact can be gauged by its successful adaptation into a TV series and the discussions it continues to generate.

“You” stands as a chilling reminder of the darkness that can lurk behind the most ordinary of facades and the blurred boundaries between love and obsession.

Caroline Kepnes’ “You” is a powerful narrative that pushes boundaries, challenges norms, and holds a magnifying glass to our digital era’s complex dynamics.

Its combination of a thrilling plot, innovative narrative style, and thought-provoking themes ensures that “You” will continue to engage, disturb, and resonate with readers long after they’ve turned the last page.


For Fans of Psychological Thrillers: “You” is a must-read for those who appreciate psychological thrillers.

Its unique narrative style, engaging plot, and deep exploration of a stalker’s mind-set make it a standout entry in the genre.

For Pop Culture Enthusiasts: If you’re someone who enjoys staying updated with trending novels and popular adaptations, “You” is an essential addition to your reading list.

It provides valuable context and a richer understanding of the widely popular Netflix adaptation.

For Societal Commentary Seekers: Readers interested in novels that offer social commentary particularly on our digital age will find much to contemplate in “You”.

The book’s exploration of social media use, online privacy, and the potential dangers of digital obsessions provides a profound reflection on our modern era.

Caution for Sensitive Readers: It’s important to note that “You” contains explicit content, including sexual scenes and violent actions.

Readers who are sensitive to such themes may want to approach with caution or consider other options.

Closing Thoughts

Unsettling Yet Captivating: “You” is an unsettling yet captivating journey into the mind of an obsessed stalker.

Its narrative style, second-person perspective, offers an intimacy and immediacy that adds a layer of complexity to the reading experience.

Masterful Blend of Genres: Caroline Kepnes masterfully blends elements of thriller, romance, and social commentary, resulting in a narrative that is at once suspenseful, disturbing, and thought-provoking.

Impactful Themes: The novel’s exploration of modern love, obsession, and the implications of our digital footprints are timely and impactful, sparking important conversations about online privacy and the nature of contemporary relationships.

A Defining Work: With its distinctive narrative voice, intricate character development, and layered themes, “You” is a defining work in the realm of psychological thrillers.

It’s a story that stays with the reader, prompting reflection on societal norms, personal actions, and the blurred lines between love and obsession.

In conclusion, “You” by Caroline Kepnes is a fascinating exploration of obsession, love, and the shadowy corners of the human mind.

By challenging readers to question societal norms and confront unsettling realities, it proves itself to be more than just a thrilling read.

It is a mirror reflecting the complexities of our digital age, making “You” a significant work that resonates in our contemporary world.

Our Rating for “You”

Narrative Voice & Style (4.8/5): Kepnes’ use of second-person narration is one of the most distinctive aspects of “You”.

This innovative storytelling approach offers an intimate and disconcerting glimpse into the mind of the protagonist, Joe Goldberg.

The language is engaging, and the suspense is deftly woven, making the reading experience unsettling yet captivating.

Character Development (4.5/5): The characters in “You” are complex, flawed, and deeply human.

Kepnes’ masterful characterization of Joe, an obsessive stalker, and Beck, his object of obsession, gives readers a profound look into their psyches.

However, some readers may find a few secondary characters less developed in comparison.

Plot & Pacing (4.7/5): The plot of “You” is engaging, with well-executed twists that keep readers on their toes.

The pacing is mostly consistent, with just a few lulls in the middle. The tension builds effectively, leading to a climax that is both surprising and inevitable.

Theme Exploration (4.9/5): “You” excels in its exploration of contemporary themes like obsession, love in the digital age, and the implications of our online behaviors.

It forces readers to reflect on societal norms and their personal actions in a way that few thrillers do, sparking thought-provoking conversations.

Impact & Resonance (4.8/5): The novel leaves a lasting impression, thanks to its chilling narrative and the unsettling realities it highlights.

It not only entertains but also prompts reflection on pressing societal concerns, making it a book that resonates beyond the final page.

Overall Rating (4.7/5): “You” by Caroline Kepnes is a standout psychological thriller that deftly combines suspense, character study, and societal critique.

Its distinctive narrative voice, complex characters, and thought-provoking themes make it a memorable read.

While it may be too intense for some, those who appreciate a gripping, thought-provoking tale will likely find “You” a compelling and worthwhile read.

In conclusion, “You” by Caroline Kepnes is a highly engaging novel that offers more than just a thrilling story.

It prompts readers to reflect on important societal issues and confront the darker aspects of human nature.

Its unique narrative voice, complex characters, and impactful themes make it an outstanding contribution to the psychological thriller genre, deserving of its high rating.


We genuinely hope our comprehensive review has covered everything you were looking for.

You can also read further reviews on Amazon.

Thank you for reading and we hope to see you back here soon!